Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Conceptual analysis reveals stages of harm from generative capability impairment in affected individuals, indicating that equal achieved outcomes can coexist with unequal freedom.
This position paper develops a conditional account of harm arising through impairment of a person's generative capability. The account begins from a specific evaluative object: the feasible and viable trajectories through which a person can initiate, sustain, direct, transform, transmit, recover, or branch a valued practice over a declared horizon. Amartya Sen's capability approach supplies the central evaluative ancestry. It directs attention from resources and achieved outputs toward real opportunities, conversion conditions, human diversity, well-being freedom, agency freedom, plural valuation, and public reasoning. The paper adds a horizon-indexed generative specialization and makes its attribution boundary explicit. Sen's framework supplies the evaluative space; the trajectory model and harm predicate are proposals developed here. The central account moves through four stages: capability contraction, material capability disadvantage, event-linked impairment, and domain-specific pro tanto harm. Each stage has an independent three-valued warrant. A complete profile retains every admitted counterfactual comparison and classifies the result as robust supported, robust rejected, baseline sensitive, or indeterminate. Duration, security, recovery probability, route-back cost, and foreclosed later branches enter the materiality assessment. A transferred conditional inclusion result establishes when a restriction contracts the reachable repertoire. Finite countermodels then establish four separations: equal achieved output can coexist with unequal capability; pro tanto harm can coexist with benefit; identical harm facts can accompany different wrongfulness statuses; and plausible comparisons can yield baseline sensitivity. The resulting account is person-centered, domain-specific, and revisable. Overall harm, injustice, exploitation, responsibility, remedy, and law remain successor inquiries with their own premises.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wanhong HUANG (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: