Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ninety years have passed since the landmarkarticlebyChevalierJackson standardizing the method of open tracheotomy. During this time, open tracheotomy has remained relatively unchallengedinitssafetyandefficacy. Recently,however,percutaneous tracheotomy has been proposed as an alternative to the conventional open technique.Asexperiencehasaccumulatedwiththepercutaneousapproach, increasing numbers of physicians in ICUs now embrace this technique. While the initial description of the percutaneous approach dates back to the 1600s, the modern-day account is attributed to Shelden et al, who in 1955 proposed the term and the procedure’s technical description. This consisted of a slot needle insertion into the trachea followed by a cutting trocar to form the tracheotomy. In 1969, Toye and Weinstein used a Seldinger technique of serial dilation of the tracheotomy, which was eventually modified by Ciaglia et al in 1985. Since that time, a variety of different techniques have evolved with different guidewires, dilators, and points of tracheal entry. Because of this variation, it is difficult to define one standard “percutaneous technique.” The common characteristics of the various percutaneous approaches include transcutaneous entry with a needle into the trachea, guidewire passage into the lumen, and serial dilation. A tracheotomy tube is subsequently passed into the lumen without an incision into the tracheal rings. Initial studies of percutaneous tracheotomy compared its safety to the historical complication rates from open tracheotomy. Since these studies were published, the medical literature has included both prospective and comparative studies comparing the safety of both techniques. The results of these studies need to be viewed critically in light of the vast experience behind open tracheotomy.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nadim B. Bikhazi (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: