Key result
The cadence-free 6-minute step test demonstrated excellent relative reproducibility (ICC > 0.8) in COPD subjects, with acceptable intra-rater error but unacceptable inter-rater error.
Why the study?
Is the cadence-free 6-minute step test reproducible in subjects with COPD?
Observational
Is the cadence-free 6-minute step test reproducible in subjects with COPD?
Effect estimate: ICC > 0.8
The cadence-free 6-minute step test is reproducible in COPD patients only when performed by the same assessor.
May support single-rater monitoring in COPD; leaves open inter-rater standardization before wider adoption.
BACKGROUND: Six-minute step test (6MST) has been used to assess functional capacity in chronic conditions; however, its reproducibility in the COPD population has not been evaluated. Our study objective was to evaluate 6MST reproducibility. METHODS: The test was performed in a single 20-cm height step, and subjects were instructed to step up and down (cadence-free) for 6 min. Subjects underwent three tests. The first and second were controlled by the same assessor with a 30-min interval. The third test was controlled by a different assessor one week later. For intra-rater comparison, the first and second performances of the test were used, and for inter-assessor comparison, the better performance of the first two tests was compared with the third test. RESULTS: Excellent intra-rater and inter-rater relative reproducibility was observed (intraclass correlation coefficient > 0.8), and there was no statistical difference (repeated measures of analysis of variance) among the performances of the three tests. Intra-rater error values were acceptable (mean error of 5.7 steps and limits of agreement between -7 and 18 steps). Inter-rater error values were not acceptable (mean error of 4.4 steps and limits of agreement between -20 and 29 steps. CONCLUSIONS: 6MST proved to be reproducible in the COPD population when performed by the same assessor.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Costa et al. (2013) conducted an observational in COPD. Cadence-Free 6-Minute Step Test was evaluated on Intra-rater and inter-rater relative reproducibility (ICC > 0.8). The cadence-free 6-minute step test demonstrated excellent relative reproducibility (ICC > 0.8) in COPD subjects, with acceptable intra-rater error but unacceptable inter-rater error.
Synapse has enriched 4 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: