Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Under the framework of phylogenetic niche conservatism, patterns of phylogenetic diversity and phylogenetic dispersion can provide insights into the environmental conditions under which major lineages originated. This approach has been widely applied to explain the well-established pattern of tropical niche conservatism in angiosperms and ferns. Bryophytes, however, are generally thought to have arisen in temperate environments. Evidence for this hypothesis exists for liverworts and, to a lesser extent, for mosses, although the two groups may not share identical evolutionary histories. Direct comparisons between them remain scarce. We investigated the relationships among phylogenetic diversity, phylogenetic dispersion, and climatic variables in liverwort and moss assemblages along four elevational gradients in subtropical eastern China. Based on a presumed temperate origin of bryophytes, we expected phylogenetic metrics to exhibit consistent responses to elevation, temperature, and precipitation. Species richness patterns were broadly similar between liverworts and mosses across all gradients. In contrast, phylogenetic structure showed marked differences, with opposing trends between the two groups in 10 of 16 comparisons. Most notably, mean pairwise distance (MPD), a metric emphasizing phylogenetic relationships that may retain stronger signals of evolutionary history at deeper divergence, declined with increasing elevation in liverworts but increased in mosses. Likewise, MPD was negatively associated with precipitation in liverworts, whereas no significant relationship was detected in mosses. These contrasting phylogenetic patterns suggest that contemporary diversity in both groups is shaped by comparable ecological preferences for cool and humid environments, yet their ancestral climatic niches may not have been identical. Although neither liverworts nor mosses appear to have originated under tropical conditions, our results indicate that mosses likely evolved under somewhat cooler and wetter climates than liverworts. Further tests of this hypothesis will require comparable analyses along elevational gradients in other regions, especially extensive tropical mountain systems encompassing a wider range of climatic conditions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Qian et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: