Comparative Study of Large Strain Methods for Assessing Failure Characteristics of Selected Food Gels

Vane rheometry was compared with uniaxial compression and torsion in evaluating the effects of strain rate on failure shear stress and deformation of soybean protein (tofu) and gellan gum gels. A Haake VT 550 viscotester was used for torsion and vane tests, and compression was performed with an Instron/MTS universal testing machine. Strain or angular deformation at failure was independent of strain rate in the three testing modes. In vane rheometry, failure shear stress increased with increasing low shear rates (< 0.100 s−1) and was rate independent at higher rates. This strain rate dependency was also evident in compression, varying with the material. For torsion, fracture stress appeared to be rate independent. Shear fracture stresses measured in torsion and compression were in good agreement at strain rates above 0.025 s−1 and 0.100 s−1 for tofu and gellan gels, respectively. Shear stresses from the vane method were lower than shear stresses of torsion and compression. Similar texture maps of the food gels studied were generated by plotting stress and strain or angular deformation values of the three testing methods. The findings validate the vane technique as an alternative to torsion and compression for rapid textural characterization of viscoelastic foods.