Key result
Airway assessment by experienced anesthesiologists improved the prediction of difficult intubation, achieving a higher sensitivity and Youden index compared to inexperienced anesthesiologists.
Why the study?
This study evaluated the impact of anaesthesiologists' experience on the prediction of difficult airway using standard assessment tools.
Does increased anesthesiologist experience improve the accuracy of predicting difficult airway in patients undergoing general endotracheal anesthesia?
RCT (n=700)
Double-blind
Computer generated table of random numbers in opaque sealed envelopes
No
Does increased anesthesiologist experience improve the accuracy of predicting difficult airway in patients undergoing general endotracheal anesthesia?
Increased clinical experience of the evaluating anesthesiologist significantly improves the accuracy and positive predictive value of the Mallampati test for predicting difficult intubation.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Experience may modestly improve Mallampati prediction accuracy; leaves open whether it changes intubation outcomes in practice.
Background: This study evaluated impact of Anaesthesiologist’s Experience on prediction of difficult airway using standard assessment tools. Methods: 700 patients scheduled to undergo surgery under General Endotracheal Anaesthesia (GETA) were included in the study. Patients were randomly divided into two groups. In group I airway assessment was done by resident anaesthesiologists (with at least 2 years of experience) and in group II airway assessment was done by a consultant anaesthesiologist (> 5 years of experience) using Mallampati scoring system and LEMON scoring system. Airway was graded as difficult or not difficult. The actual presence/ absence of a difficult endotracheal intubation were reported by a consultant anaesthesiologist unaware of the prediction. These findings were compared to the pre anaesthetic evaluation finding to determine correct/incorrect prediction of difficult airway. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value and Youden index were determined for all tests. Results: Difficult tracheal intubation occurred in 3% (21 patients) case and no failed intubation occurred. Group I had Sensitivity 55.56%,specificity 97.95%, PPV64.29%, YOUDEN index 0.54, ODD’S ratio 59.64 % while Group 2 had sensitivity of 64.29%,specificity of 98.51%, PPV 64.29% YOUDEN INDEX 0.63, ODD’S ratio 119.16. Conclusions: The present study suggests that increased experience of the evaluating Anaesthesiologists enhances the accuracy of Mallampati test for predicting difficult intubation with higher sensitivity, PPV and YOUDENS index when compared to evaluation done by inexperienced Anaesthesiologists.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bedi et al. (2020) conducted an RCT in Difficult airway prediction (n=700). Airway assessment by experienced anesthesiologist (>5 years experience) vs. Airway assessment by inexperienced anesthesiologist (≥2 years experience) was evaluated on Sensitivity for predicting difficult intubation. Airway assessment by experienced anesthesiologists improved the prediction of difficult intubation, achieving a higher sensitivity and Youden index compared to inexperienced anesthesiologists.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: