Key result
Family screening of 38 relatives of a patient with Marfan syndrome identified 10 new definite and 5 possible cases across 4 generations, all without ocular involvement.
Why the study?
What is the diagnostic yield and what are the psychosocial consequences of screening relatives of a patient with Marfan syndrome?
Observational (n=38)
What is the diagnostic yield and what are the psychosocial consequences of screening relatives of a patient with Marfan syndrome?
Family screening for Marfan syndrome effectively identifies previously undiagnosed at-risk individuals but may also cause psychological, social, and financial drawbacks.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Family screening may detect additional Marfan cases without ocular features; leaves open net benefit given potential psychosocial harms.
Thirty eight relatives of a patient with Marfan syndrome were screened for the presence of this disorder. Marfan syndrome was newly diagnosed in living members of 4 generations in this family without evidence of ocular abnormality in any. After screening, 10 relatives were newly diagnosed as having definite, and 5 relatives as having possible, Marfan syndrome. Family screening has drawbacks as well as benefits for the patients. The main benefit is the identification and treatment of previously undiagnosed patients at risk of cardiac complications which are the major cause of mortality. The drawbacks include employment problems created for patients with Marfan syndrome as a direct consequence of our screening programme and the anxiety induced in previously asymptomatic family members who did not realize that they could be at risk. Also, the 4 adult patients with possible Marfan syndrome found it difficult to accept that a definite diagnosis could not be reached after they had been invited to attend a screening programme for a serious genetic disorder. This report illustrates the importance of screening all the relatives of a patient with Marfan syndrome to identify previously undiagnosed cases. However, before screening a family, the physician should be aware that a clear diagnosis may not be reached in all patients, and financial, psychological or social problems may arise as a result of the screening programme.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bridges et al. (1991) conducted an observational in Marfan syndrome (n=38). Family screening was evaluated on Diagnosis of Marfan syndrome. Family screening of 38 relatives of a patient with Marfan syndrome identified 10 new definite and 5 possible cases across 4 generations, all without ocular involvement.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: