Key result
Canadian aged people showed a higher average score in more SDS items compared with Japanese aged people (mean SDS index 44.34 vs 44.03), indicating more clear expression of depressed moods.
Why the study?
Are there differences in the expression of depressed mood between Japanese and Canadian aged people?
Cross-Sectional (n=2,363)
Yes
Are there differences in the expression of depressed mood between Japanese and Canadian aged people?
Canadian aged people appear to express their depressed moods more clearly and spontaneously than Japanese aged people.
OBJECTIVE: To investigate differences of expression regarding depressed mood between Japanese and Canadian aged people. METHOD: The Zung Self-Rating Depression Scale (SDS) was applied to people aged 65 and over in Ohira, Japan, and Steveston, British Columbia, Canada. RESULTS: The number of subjects who filled out the SDS completely was 2180 for the Japanese sample and 183 for the Canadian sample. The mean SDS indexes of the Japanese and the Canadian samples were 44.03 and 44.34, respectively. The Canadian sample showed a higher average score in 11 items out of 20, whereas the Japanese sample showed a higher score on only 4 items. The factor analysis of those samples showed only small differences. CONCLUSIONS: The Canadian sample showed a higher average score in more items compared with the Japanese sample. This indicates that Canadian aged people express their depressed moods more clearly and spontaneously than Japanese aged people.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Komahashi et al. (1997) conducted a cross-sectional in Depressed mood (n=2,363). Canadian nationality/culture vs. Japanese nationality/culture was evaluated on Mean Zung Self-Rating Depression Scale (SDS) index. Canadian aged people showed a higher average score in more SDS items compared with Japanese aged people (mean SDS index 44.34 vs 44.03), indicating more clear expression of depressed moods.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: