Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
INVESTIGATIONS concerning the antibacterial effects exhibited by dental restorative materials have been limited. In most instances, the materials were tested using gram-negative and gram-positive organisms, with no attempt being made to correlate these tests with the organisms usually considered to be associated with dental caries. For this reason, we chose to use Lactobacillus case, Clostridiumn bifermentans, and Streptococcus viridxtns, studying the antibacterial action of several commonly used restorative materials on organisms which we regard to be most closely related to the various process. Naegeli, in 1893, was the first to observe that algae were killed when placed in water in contact with copper.1 He termed this phenomenon the oligodynamic 'action of metals. In a further study of this phenomenon, he observed that arsenic possessed the greatest oligodynamic action and, in decreasing order of action, mercury, copper, and silver; lead, gold, and iron did not demonstrate this property. All the bacteria were not equally influenced: the gram-positive organisms were influenced more than the gram-negative organisms.2 At the close of the nineteenth century, Miller pointed out that certain gold preparations had a bactericidal action; he stated that this bactericidal action was absent in mat gold and was lost when gold foil was annealed. Later, it was observed that mercury, silver, and copper were capable of arresting the growth on agar plates of Staphylococcus aureus, Bacterium coli, Bacterium pyocyaneum, and Eberthella typhosa.2 Staub found tin and cylinder gold to be incapable of arresting the development of Bacterium prodigiosum.2 Pickerill noted that copper amalgam and zinc phosphate cement were the only dental restorative materials that exhibited appreciable antiseptic action on a mixed culture of organisms obtained from various dentin. Staub found that copper, silver, and mercury effectively inhibited the growth of Bacterium coli, Bacterium pyocyaneum, and Staphylococcus aureus in vitro, but no action was seen with either gold or tin. The action of the metals was greater on Bacterium coli and Sta~phylococcus aureus than on Bacterium pyocyaneun.2 Hill and Boester observed that most of the commercial cements were sufficiently germicidal for clinical purposes. They tested these cements against Staphylococcus aureus after allowing the specimens to set for 24 hours to permit the elimination of the free phosphoric acid.5
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shay et al. (1956) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: