Key result
Central venous catheter tips should not be intentionally positioned in the right atrium due to increased risks of perforation and arrhythmias, and placement should be confirmed with imaging.
Why the study?
Does positioning the CVC tip in the SVC rather than the RA prevent perforation and arrhythmias in children?
Does positioning the CVC tip in the SVC rather than the RA prevent perforation and arrhythmias in children?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Positioning central venous catheter tips in the superior vena cava rather than the right atrium in children provides a greater margin of safety against perforation and arrhythmias.
In Response: We appreciate Dr. Bahk’s comments about optimal location for central venous catheter (CVC) placement in children. We agree that CVCs parallel to the superior vena cava (SVC) wall, whether high, mid, or low SVC, are much less likely to perforate the vessel (1). We also agree that right subclavian catheters have a higher incidence of being positioned across the midline, and may migrate after placement if left too high (2). Lower positioning in the low SVC with right subclavian CVC may be preferable because a longer length of catheter is parallel to the vein wall and less likely to migrate. We also agree that a CVC tip high in the right atrium (RA) that stays fixed in position, well away from the free wall, poses little risk of perforation. However, we believe that positioning the CVC tip above the RA confers a greater margin of safety, particularly during “blind” insertion methods where the CVC will not be imaged for several hours. Thus our arguments that CVC tips should not be intentionally positioned in the RA are as follows. 1. As noted in our article, 90% of CVC perforations occur with catheter tips in the RA or right ventricle and only 10% when in the SVC (1). 2. RA CVC may cause arrhythmias, specifically premature atrial contractions, supraventricular tachycardia, and ectopic atrial tachycardia (3). 3. The RA contracts vigorously but the SVC does not. Thus the RA free wall is not fixed in position, and if the CVC is in any other place but the high RA (i.e., in the mid or low RA, in the appendage, or at an acute angle to the RA wall), perforation risk is increased because of the contraction of the free wall of the RA against the CVC tip (4). 4. The CVC tip will migrate up to several cm distally with head and neck movement (5), arm movement, and respiratory variation. If the tip is already in the RA, distal movement may perforate the free wall of the RA. 5. Surgical manipulation, either of the heart itself, or with retraction in the right upper quadrant may lead to distal migration of the CVC tip and perforation (6). 6. Examination of our data reveals a wide variation in the location of the SVC/RA junction in any individual patient. During blind insertion methods, allowing a lower tip position may lead to a greater percentage of CVC in the mid or low RA, leading to increased perforation risk. The few CVC tips in our series that were in the RA were all within 1 cm of the SVC/RA junction. One may consider placing the CVC tip high in the SVC to be preferable because perforation at this level is above the pericardial reflection and less likely to cause tamponade. Perforation in the RA may, of course, lead to catastrophe (7,8). During several hundred transesophageal echocardiographically guided CVC placements (2), we have observed the distance from the SVC/RA junction to the RA free wall to be only 2–3 cm or less in patients weighing less than 10 kg. Therefore, a seemingly small migration of the tip may place the CVC much deeper in the RA and at increased perforation risk. We combined right subclavian and right internal jugular data because, after separate evaluation, the proposed guidelines for the depth of insertion were the same for both groups. Combining the data meant that one set of clinically useful guidelines could be made for both insertion sites, with a high degree of success in predicted proper placement, i.e., 97% for all CVC versus 99% and 93% for right internal jugular and right subclavian alone, respectively, when using the height based formulae, and similar success predicted when using the weight-based formulae. In our opinion, given the individual variation in each patient, the best method to ensure proper placement is to image the CVC tip as soon as possible. Transesophageal echocardiography, if available, is useful because the tip position can be easily adjusted before final securing (2). If this is not possible, chest radiography should be performed as soon as possible to confirm tip position. In certain difficult or questionable cases, immediate radiography in the operating room before the start of a long surgical procedure may be indicated. Dean B. Andropoulos, MD Stephen A.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Andropoulos et al. (2002) conducted a letter in Central venous catheter placement in children. Central venous catheter placement was evaluated. Central venous catheter tips should not be intentionally positioned in the right atrium due to increased risks of perforation and arrhythmias, and placement should be confirmed with imaging.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: