Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Aim: to measure the degree of instability in patients with impingement syndrome.Methodology: A single blinded, randomised, controlled study. Twenty-four subjects were recruited, (12 women and 12 men, with mean age 29.17 years). The first group (experimental) consisted of 12 individuals of both sexes, with the diagnosis of shoulder impingement syndrome. The other 12 were the control group. Altcheck’s grading system recommended by Altcheck et al (1989), a standardised procedure was carried out on all subjects to measure instability/translation.Results: There were 8 shoulders (33%) with grade 0 anterior laxity, 8 (33%) with 1+ and 8 (33%) 2+ anterior laxity. Eight shoulders (33%) with grade 0 posterior laxity, 12 (50%) 1+ and 4 (16%) with grade 2+ posterior laxity. No shoulder examined had grade 3+ laxity in either direction.Analysis by Mann-Whitney showed that there was no significant relationship between instability/translation and the impingement syndrome. There was no relationship between the amount of translation within the two groups. However, a significant difference was noted in the amount of anterior translation as opposed to posterior translation in all subjects.Conclusion: This investigation revealed no correlation between impingement syndrome and anterior/posterior instability of the shoulder. Unfortunately, we are unable to make a suitable comparison with other studies due to the diverse and different methodologies that other authors have employed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Abrahams et al. (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: