This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Developmental studies focused on establishment of baseline information for forensically important insects generally suffer from a lack of standard procedures for collecting the data (Amendt et al. 2011, Tarone and Foran 2011, Rivers and Dahlem 2014). This is perhaps most evident with research involving necrophagous flies, in which one of the major assumptions—accurate determination of fly age—for calculating portions of the postmortem interval has been inadvertently violated in numerous published studies. In their Letter to the Editor (JME 53(6), 2016, 1249-1251), Daniel Martin-Vega, Martin Hall, and Thomas Simonsen correctly identify a reoccurring weakness that plagues such studies performed with necrophagous flies: misclassification of life stages occurring within puparia. As noted by Hinton (1971) and Fraenkel and Bhaskaran (1973), three distinct phases of development occur within the enclosed puparia of cyclorrhaphous Diptera: prepupal, pupal, and pharate adult. Martin-Vega et al. (2016) provide an excellent overview of the terminology for intrapuparial developmental stages, and also detail how each stage can be distinguished histologically or through the use of advanced techniques like micro-CT scans (although Fig. 1 on page 1250 of their article is only relevant if the developmental temperature is also provided). Their recommendation of using the term “intrapuparial period” to replace the often-incorrect label of “pupal stage” in developmental studies actually taps at a bigger issue in forensic entomology. Many research articles that present developmental data on a range of fly species generally have not consulted any literature beyond that of forensic entomology. This has contributed, in part, to the confusion in terminology discussed by Martin-Vega et al (2016). Such oversight has also led to errors (from relatively minor to significant) in experimental design and data interpretation that have become systemic to the field. In addition to the obvious issues identified by Martin-Vega et al. (2016), namely, the influence on estimations of the minimum postmortem interval (minPMI) dependent on intrapuparial stages, others exist with relation to developmental studies involving both necrophagous Diptera and parasitic Hymenoptera. For example, there are no standard operating protocols that take into consideration the influence of variation in maggot mass sizes on developmental thresholds or rates of development at constant or fluctuating rearing temperatures (Rivers and Dahlem 2014). A similar lack of guidelines exists in relation to selection of food sources for larval development, or in the determination of the onset or completion of key developmental events, such as adult emergence: Does this occur when the first fly ecloses from a puparium, when 50% of the sample population ecloses, or some other value? The latter is obviously relevant to all stages of development, including those that occur during the intrapuparial period, yet very few studies actually report the criteria used for determining the length of specific development stages. Why such details are needed is obvious; the length of specific developmental stages is highly variable and species-dependent. Using adult emergence as an example, in the flesh fly, Sarcophaga crassipalpis Marquet (Diptera: Sarcophagidae), extrication from puparia occurs over a 3-5-d window at 25 °C, but increases in length as ambient temperatures elevate to near the upper thermal limit (Yocum et al. 1994). In the latter scenario, emergence of the first fly to the last may be separated by as much as 10 d. Again, the question arises as to what percentage of the flies is being recorded to assess that emergence (or any other developmental stage) has been completed on a particular day? A similar temperature effect occurs during intrapuparial development for Sarcophagabullata Parker and Sarcophagahaemorrhoidalis Fallên, in which rearing temperatures above 30 °C accelerate larval growth, but yield a delay in pupal development (Byrd and Butler 1998, Rivers et al. 2010). The delay is not an arrestment, and in fact, all aspects of pharate adult development, at least for S. bullata, occur more rapidly than observed at lower ambient temperatures (Rivers et al. 2010). This example highlights the need for accurate determination of intrapuparial stages of development in studies examining parameters of temperature-dependent growth in necrophagous flies. Standard operating procedures are equally important for other forensic indicator species, but the lack of such guidelines generally has not been mentioned in the research literature, because carrion breeding flies dominate most aspects of medicocriminal entomology. Developmental studies involving forensically important parasitic wasps are markedly more complex than those involving necrophagous flies. In the case of the so-called “pupal parasitoids” of necrophagous flies, clarification of the terminology associated with host intrapuparial stages is critical for determination of minPMI based on wasp development. As discussed by Rivers and Losinger (2014) and Rivers (2016), the host condition must be considered, which includes host species, age, physiological state (non-diapausing vs. diapausing), size, and whether the host has previously been parasitized, when performing developmental studies with parasitic wasps. Each of these host features influences female fecundity as well as the length of larval development (Godfray 1994). The reality is that most studies that have appeared in the forensic entomology literature using pupal parasitoids, most commonly Nasonia vitripennis (Walker) (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae), have not controlled for the host condition. This is readily apparent when comparing the different development times reported for N. vitripennis when reared on different fly species of differing ages (Grassberger and Frank 2003, Mello and Coelho 2009, Mello et al. 2009, Voss et al. 2010). The letter by Martin-Vega et al. (2016) to clarify the terminology used in developmental stages involving necrophagous flies should be used as a call for the discipline to continue moving toward standard operating procedures in an effort to avoid confusion and misinterpretations with respect to developmental studies. Perhaps the next steps involve the North American Forensic Entomology Association and European Association for Forensic Entomology to form a task force that is charged with development of a framework of standard procedures for conducting developmental studies. The benefit of such an effort is to ensure that the baseline data being generated and published in forensic entomology have utility when applied to legal issues.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
David Rivers (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: