Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Conceptual analysis uncovers evolving human-nature relations across social theory, highlighting persistent tensions between control, care, and ecological interdependence.
An examination of social figures reveals that ecological relationships remain largely overlooked in sociological theorizing. This article introduces the gardener as an ecological social figure that brings nature, materiality, and social relations into an analytical frame. Drawing on Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Zygmunt Bauman, Friedrich Hayek, Anna Lowenhaupt Tsing, and Donna Haraway, I trace how the gardener figures different ways of organizing human—nature relations from modernity to late- and postmodernity. In modern accounts, Rousseau and Bauman associate the gardener with education, planning, classification, and control, but in distinct ways. Rousseau figures the educator as a gardener who nurtures children's natural development, while Bauman conceptualizes the modern state as a gardener that cultivates social order through the exclusion and normalization of “weeds.” While the gardener remains largely a metaphorical figure in modern and late-modern accounts, Tsing and Haraway ground the figure in engagements with the materiality of the garden. Hayek, Tsing, and Haraway reconfigure the figure by foregrounding limited human control and nonhuman agency, with Tsing and Haraway emphasizing multispecies relations of care, gathering, and composting. Yet this reconfiguration does not constitute a straightforward historical movement from domination to care. Rather, late- and postmodern figurations remain entangled with earlier logics: Hayek retains control through institutional governance, Tsing reintroduces selection and eradication when invasive species threaten multispecies life, and Haraway retains a central role for human actors and biopolitical regulation. The gardener provides a heuristic for examining the coexistence and negotiation of competing logics of cultivation, control, care, autonomy, selection, and ecological interdependence. Drawing on Auerbach's concept of figura , I argue that social figures need not be restricted to human subjects but can encompass nonhuman beings, materialities, and ecological processes. The gardener thereby opens a post-anthropocentric perspective on social relations while revealing the persistent tensions through which contemporary human–nature relations are organized.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christian Helge Peters (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: