Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
QUESTION: My question pertains to the rating of impairment for reported facet arthropathy with callus formation and whether this would meet the criteria for alteration of motion segment integrity. A colleague of mine saw a patient at the request of the patient's attorney and opined that bone formation at the C5-C6 facet was an “inherent attempt at arthrodesis” and therefore, per the AMA Guides, Fifth Edition, it would be rated as “alteration of motion segment integrity,” ie, diagnosis-related estimate (DRE) category IV at 25% to 28% whole person impairment (WPI). He suggested the patient met the criteria in Table 15-5, Criteria for Rating Impairment Due to Cervical Disorders (5th ed, 392), “due to a developmental fusion or successful or unsuccessful attempt at surgical arthrodesis.” Three months following the patient's evaluation, a cervical magnetic resonance image (MRI) revealed normal findings at the C5-C6 level, including normal facet joints. This same physician said that there is a C6 radiculopathy on the basis of slight thumb extension weakness and decreased grip strength; however, the patient has normal sensory examination and reflexes. No other physician has determined the patient has radiculopathy, and no electrodiagnostic studies have been performed. On examination, there were no ratable findings per Box 15-1, Definitions of Clinical Findings Used to Place an Individual in a DRE Category (5th ed, 382-383).Would you share some guidance on providing an accurate assessment?ANSWER: Equating degenerative changes of facets with an “inherent attempt at arthrodesis” is creative but inconsistent with definitions in both the Fifth and Sixth Editions of the AMA Guides. Degenerative changes of facet joints are neither a developmental fusion nor a surgical attempt at arthrodesis.Facet arthropathy (ie, osteo- or degenerative arthritis or arthrosis of facet joints) occurs over time, and to a greater or lesser extent, in all persons due to a combination of genetic determinants1, 2 and aging.3 However, facet arthropathy may be accelerated by other factors including trauma (eg, cervical injury sustained in a high-speed motor vehicle collision); abnormal spinal alignment (eg, moderate to severe anterolisthesis or scoliosis); or fusion of an adjacent motion segment, usually iatrogenic but sometimes spontaneous, with resultant adjacent segment degeneration.In medicine, callus refers to the thickening of skin in response to repeated pressure or friction, or the initially cartilaginous and subsequently bony bridge connecting fracture fragments. Absent any mention of a fracture in this case, the “callus formation” presumably means a marginal osteophyte (bone spur), one of the cardinal manifestations of joint degeneration, along with joint space narrowing, subchondral sclerosis, and in more severe cases, subchondral cyst formation.Most middle-aged to elderly persons have at least some marginal osteophytosis of cervical uncovertebral and/or facet joints. Spur formation begins with dysregulated chondrogenesis in the periosteum at the junction of cartilage and bone in diarthrodial joints, initially forming a chondrophyte, which eventually ossifies into an osteophyte.4-6 Small osteophytes may be advantageous in degenerated joints, increasing joint stability and possibly widening the area upon which loads are distributed, thereby protecting remaining articular cartilage. Large osteophytes may limit joint motion, and occasionally grow big enough to fuse with a spur projecting from the apposing joint surface, creating a bony bridge across the articulation.7 However, it is incorrect to state any marginal osteophyte is an “inherent attempt at arthrodesis.” Even if this were true, it does not meet any of the criteria listed for DRE for cervical category IV. Specifically, it is not a developmental fusion or successful or unsuccessful attempt at surgical arthrodesis. Developmental refers to something that occurred during embryonic, fetal, or childhood development. An “inherent [or perhaps more accurately stated spontaneous] attempt at arthrodesis” is not a successful or unsuccessful attempt at surgical arthrodesis.Based on the information provided, there is no evidence of a C6 radiculopathy. As noted in Table 15-2, Common Radicular Syndromes (5th ed, 376), and Table 17-8, Common Radicular Syndromes (6th ed, 578), a C5 radiculopathy often results in deltoid and/or biceps weakness; C6 radiculopathy radial wrist extensor and/or biceps weakness; C7 radiculopathy wrist flexors, triceps, finger extensors, and/or ulnar wrist extensor weakness; and C8 radiculopathy weakness of finger flexion and hand intrinsic muscles. The case scenario says thumb extensor weakness but does not isolate the weakness to the extensor pollicis longus (thumb interphalangeal joint extension) or to the extensor pollicis brevis (thumb metacarpophalangeal joint extension). Both muscles are typically supplied by the C7 and the C8 nerve roots, not by the C6 nerve root. Hence, this patient does not have weakness consistent with C6 radiculopathy. In addition, there is no sensory loss in C6 dermatome (lateral forearm, wrist, hand, and digits [thumb and index finger]), or diminution in or absence of brachioradialis deep tendon reflex, both of which would be expected with a C6 radiculopathy. Given the absence of motor, sensory, and reflex abnormalities consistent with C6 radiculopathy, almost certainly the patient does not have this condition.However, your colleague reportedly found weakness of grip strength and thumb extension, both of which could be explained by a C8 radiculopathy. Deep tendon reflexes are usually normal with an isolated C8 radiculopathy. However, if there is C8 nerve root impingement, one would expect accompanying sensory loss in C8 dermatome, ie, medial forearm, wrist, hand, and digits (ring and little fingers). Absent this, and especially given the apparent inter-examiner unreliability since no “other physician has determined that he has radiculopathy,” it would be imprudent to conclude the patient has a C8 radiculopathy without corroborating electromyogram findings.Therefore, based on the clinical information provided, the patient should not be rated for alteration of motion segment integrity or radiculopathy. Impairment ratings must be based on valid and reliable clinical findings, causally related to the subject injury or illness; and the evaluator must follow the processes specified in the AMA Guides.Using the AMA Guides, Fifth Edition, the patient would be rated using the DRE method. The rating of a cervical (neck) injury is performed according to Section 15.6, DRE: Cervical Spine (5th ed, 392-395), and Table15.5, Criteria for Rating Impairment Due to Cervical Disorders (5th ed, 392). Although not supported by the cervical MRI scan, if asked to assume there is minimal or mild C5-C6 facet arthropathy, but no cervical fracture and none of the findings listed in Box 15-1, Definitions of Clinical Findings Used to Place an Individual in a DRE category (5th ed, 382), the classification would be DRE cervical category I in Table 15-5, with 0% WPI, because there are “no significant clinical findings, no muscle guarding, no documentable neurologic impairment, no significant loss of motion segment integrity, and no other indication of impairment related to injury or illness; no fractures” (5th ed, 392).Using the AMA Guides, Sixth Edition, evaluation of impairment due to cervical strain is based on Section 17.2, Diagnosis-Based Impairment (6th ed, 560), and Section 17.2a, Cervical Spine (6th ed, 563). In Table 17-2, Cervical Spine Regional Grid: Spine Impairments (6th ed, 564-566), for the diagnosis of “non-specific chronic or chronic, recurrent cervical spine pain (also known as chronic sprain/strain, symptomatic degenerative disc disease, facet joint pain [emphasis added], chronic whiplash, etc)” Class 1 would be warranted assuming there is a “history of sprain/strain-type injury, with continued complaints of axial and/or non-verifiable radicular complaints.” The default impairment value is 2% whole person.For non-specific spinal pain, adjustments are made for functional history, but not physical examination or clinical studies. Per Section 17.3a, Adjustment Grid: Functional History (6th ed, 569), and Table 17-6, Functional History Adjustment: Spine (6th ed, 575), if the patient has “pain, symptoms with normal activity,” grade modifier 2 would be warranted, using the net adjustment formula: (GMFH–CDX) = (2–1) = 1. Hence, the final grade is D, which constitutes 3% WPI.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brooks et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: