Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Pteridium aquilinum is a problematic, perennial, invasive species worldwide that poses serious problems in the British uplands. However, there is a lack of knowledge on long-term success in terms of weed control and land improvement. We assessed the effects of six P. aquilinum-control treatments at two acid-grassland sites in the Scottish Borders (Sourhope 1 & 2). There were six treatments: (i) untreated, (ii) cutting once-yearly, (iii) cutting twice-yearly, (iv) asulam sprayed in year 1, (v) cutting once in year 1/asulam in year 2, and (vi) asulam in year 1/cut in year 2. The annual cutting treatments were stopped after 9/10 years. We measured the response of three variables over 25/26-years assessing P. aquilinum-performance, agricultural-improvement and species richness. We estimated the treatment “effect window”, defined as the period over which the P. aquilinum-control treatments had a significant effect relative to untreated experimental-controls. Results were completely different for all variables in the two experiments. At Sourhope 1 the cutting treatments had much longer “effect windows” than the herbicide-based treatments in reducing P. aquilinum performance, especially the cut twice-yearly treatment with a 25-year window. At Sourhope 2, the treatment differences were much reduced with the best treatment (cut twice yearly) producing a 13-year window. At both experiments, asulam-based treatments produce a minimum “effect window” of 10 years. Increases in both the agricultural-improvement index and species richness were also obtained at both sites. “Effect windows” for both agricultural-improvement index (TVI) and species richness also showed some improvement; “effect windows” were obtained of 12–20 and 9–20 years for TVI, and 7–17 and 2–10 years for species richness at Sourhope 1 and Sourhope 2 respectively. Species richness declined though time in both experiments. Cutting, and preferably twice per year, was the most effective treatment but also the costliest, with the most cost-effective approach being a single asulam spray. However, the length of the “effect windows” suggest that repeat-spraying every 10-years is needed. Unfortunately, where the aim is to recover biodiversity interventionist techniques such as seeding will also be needed. The use of “effect windows” for estimating long-term impact of perennial weed control is novel and may be of use in other situations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Akpınar et al. (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: