Key result
Right shoulder pain occurred in 42% of patients after hepatectomy and was more frequent in those receiving combined epidural and general anesthesia than general anesthesia alone.
Why the study?
Does epidural anaesthesia combined with general anaesthesia affect the incidence of right shoulder pain after hepatectomy compared to general anaesthesia alone?
Does epidural anaesthesia combined with general anaesthesia affect the incidence of right shoulder pain after hepatectomy compared to general anaesthesia alone?
Right shoulder pain is common after hepatectomy and is more frequent with combined epidural and general anesthesia, suggesting it is a referred pain not blocked by epidural analgesia and requires systemic opioids.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Shoulder pain after hepatectomy may reflect phrenic nerve irritation; hypothesis-generating for targeted analgesia trials.
Editor, Shoulder pain resulting from invasive irritation of the diaphragm mediated by phrenic nerve has been speculated to be a type of referred pain.1 In abdominal surgery, especially laparoscopic surgery such as laparoscopic cholecystectomy2 and laparoscopic adjustable gastric banding,3 shoulder pain has been noted. There are some case reports in which shoulder pain occurred after a hepatectomy.4 As most surgical manipulations of a hepatectomy are limited to the right diaphragm, shoulder pain after a hepatectomy should occur on the right side. Because the characteristics, including laterality of shoulder pain after a hepatectomy, have not been discussed in detail, we investigated postoperative shoulder pain in patients who underwent a hepatectomy. Ethical approval for this study (dai eki-936 gou) was provided by the Ethical Committee of Hiroshima University Hospital, Hiroshima, Japan (University president, Toshimasa Asahara) on 30 April 2014. Medical records of patients who underwent an elective hepatectomy from October 2011 to April 2013 were retrospectively reviewed. In every patient, the hepatectomy was performed by an reversed L-shaped incision in a supine position by placing both arms cephalad. General anaesthesia was maintained with sevoflurane, remifentanil and intermittent administration of fentanyl. Epidural anaesthesia was combined with general anaesthesia if applicable. Epidural anaesthesia was maintained with a continuous infusion of 0.25 or 0.3% ropivacaine at a rate of 4 to 6 ml h−1 during surgery. Predicted blood concentration of the sum of fentanyl and remifentanil at the end of surgery were calculated from Shafer's model and Minto's model, respectively. After emergence from anaesthesia in the recovery room, patients were asked about the presence or absence of shoulder pain. We investigated the incidence and laterality of the shoulder pain. Welch's t-test and a Chi-square test were used for statistical analyses, with significance set at P < 0.05. Data are shown as means ± standard deviation. Of 215 patients who underwent a hepatectomy during the study period, accurate records concerning the presence or absence of shoulder pain in the recovery room existed in 50, and those patients were anaesthetised by a single anaesthetist. Right shoulder pain occurred in 21 of 50 patients (42%). Shoulder pain only on the right side was observed in 17 patients and on both sides in four, whereas none had shoulder pain only on the left side. Furthermore, shoulder pain occurred more frequently in patients who had received epidural anaesthesia combined with general anaesthesia than general anaesthesia alone (P < 0.01). The predicted blood level of the sum of fentanyl and remifentanil at the end of surgery was significantly lower in patients with right shoulder pain than those without (0.51 ± 0.33 vs. 0.99 ± 0.94 ng ml−1, P = 0.02). To the best of our knowledge, there have been no reports regarding the incidence and laterality of shoulder pain after hepatectomy. We found that the incidence of shoulder pain after hepatectomy was significantly higher on the right side (42%) than the left side. Schumann et al.4 proposed that the mechanism of such shoulder pain is a misidentification of diaphragmatic irritation caused by stimulation of the sensory nerve to the shoulder area on the path of neural transmission. However, the influence of myofascial pain by intraoperative posture was not taken into consideration in the previous reports. Shoulder pain in the present cases occurred more frequently on the right side despite the fact that all of our patients underwent surgical procedure with both arms in a cephalad position. Thus, we considered that shoulder pain occurring after a hepatectomy is not a type of myofascial pain caused by intraoperative posture. In light of our findings, we speculate that shoulder pain occurring at the right side after a hepatectomy is a type of referred pain resulting from invasive irritation of the diaphragm. In the present cohort, right shoulder pain occurred more frequently in those who received epidural anaesthesia combined with general anaesthesia than those with general anaesthesia alone. When considering that such shoulder pain is a type of phrenic nerve mediated referred pain from diaphragm invasion, this result is inevitable because the neural transmission route is not blocked by epidural anaesthesia. On the contrary, the amount of fentanyl used during surgery was significantly less in patients anaesthetised with a combination of epidural and general anaesthesia, as compared with general anaesthesia alone. Furthermore, the predicted blood level of the sum of fentanyl and remifentanil at the end of surgery was significantly lower in patients with right shoulder pain. Together, these results suggest that shoulder pain occurring after a hepatectomy is not affected by epidural analgesia and must be controlled by the systemic administration of an opioid. Acknowledgements relating to the article Assistance with the letter: none. Financial support and sponsorship: none. Conflicts of interest: none.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Miyoshi et al. (2015) conducted a letter in Postoperative shoulder pain after hepatectomy (n=50). Epidural anaesthesia combined with general anaesthesia vs. General anaesthesia alone was evaluated on Incidence of right shoulder pain (p=<0.01). Right shoulder pain occurred in 42% of patients after hepatectomy and was more frequent in those receiving combined epidural and general anesthesia than general anesthesia alone.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: