Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
As preceptors, we usually encounter two types of students. Some do well with structured classroom activities and taking tests, but they struggle when confronted with new challenges in the clinical setting. Others have excellent interpersonal skills yet lack the knowledge base or critical thinking skills necessary to function adequately in the clinic. These individuals highlight the multitude of skills, attitudes, and behaviors required to become an audiologist, and these characteristics are ones that must be learned. Students should arrive at their externships with a solid theoretical foundation as well as clinical experiences in at least the basics of audiologic diagnostics and treatment. Their nascent skills and attitudes should be developing and ready for further refinement, and having an understanding of the progressive nature of the learning process will provide you with a framework from which to view student development and structure your clinical teaching. LEARNING DOMAINS Most clinical activities require three learning domains—cognitive, psychomotor, and affective—and one social domain. Bloom's Taxonomy of Learning breaks those domains into progressively more complex stages where each step must be mastered before moving on to the next.1 (Tables 1-3.) Be mindful that it may not be the material's difficulty when a student has a problem learning specific subject matter, but rather the level at which you are asking them to function. Moving to a lower level may alleviate the problem. Bloom's verbs are useful for measuring mastery and developing learning objectives for each level. “You do not really understand something unless you can explain it to your grandmother.” –Albert EinsteinTable 1: Cognitive DomainTable 2: Psychomotor DomainTable 3: Affective DomainLEARNING STYLES No universal method of learning or teaching works for everyone, and each student's style tends to be influenced by a number of factors including personality, intelligence, culture, and sensory and cognitive preferences. Those preferences are especially obvious when we learn new material, but as learning proceeds, we are likely to employ modes other than those we prefer.2 Because there is no one learning style that is best for all tasks, modifying your teaching approach based on the situation will help to establish a collaborative effort with the learner. When choosing your teaching approach, consider the student's prior level of knowledge, ability, and interests as well as the nature of the task that is being taught.3 Using a variety of methods for communicating information is ideal. The most effective approach is to use demonstration, have the student practice, and then teach the skill to someone else. (Figure 1.) This approach was discussed in the July 2011 issue. (http://bit.ly/PreceptorPart2.) Adults learn best by doing, and the more senses involved during learning, the greater the retention. ADULT LEARNING THEORIES Andragogy, a term introduced by Knowles to highlight the difference between learning in adults and children, takes into account that adults like autonomy and problem-solving.4 To successfully teach adult learners, preceptors and learners pursue knowledge together. This requires establishing a positive climate for learning in which feedback, dialogue, and asking questions is encouraged.5 (Additional suggestions in Table 4.) But barriers to adult learning exist—low self-esteem, lack of confidence in one's abilities, and fear of ridicule or failure—and teachers have to help students overcome them.Table 4: Recommendations for incorporating adult learning theory into the clinicThe responsibility for learning by adults should be placed on the student. While all of your students will be adults, not all of them may function as adult learners. You will know that the learner is functioning as an adult when there is a change in his motivation from an external focus on grades, honors, and awards to an internal focus on the value of knowledge and skill. Adult learners will be inclined to buy into the process so they become internally motivated and feel in control. The student will also develop the ability for critical reflection and lifelong learning as he becomes an adult learner.6 PROFESSIONALISM Graduates of audiology doctoral programs should be capable of providing excellence in hearing and balance care in a professional way. Unlike the other domains of learning, the focus of the professional domain is on performance. Brown and Ferrill recently proposed a taxonomy of professionalism that includes competency, connection, and character.7 The clinical setting is the ideal place for learners to change from the role of student to professional. Preceptors can facilitate this transformation by encouraging self-reflection and providing feedback concerning the experiences. Preceptors also play an extremely important role in the process by serving as role models.8 Ask yourself if you and your staff adhere to the same standards and expectations that you have for your students, not only in clinical competence but also in personal qualities. Set high standards and provide frequent feedback to help students develop positive professional behaviors. (Table 5.)Table 5: Strategies for encouraging the development of professionalismGENERATIONAL ISSUES Conflict, tension, and misunderstandings can occur if differences in expectations exist between preceptors and learners. Age and generational differences are a source of potential strain. Understanding the characteristics of different generations can make a difference in helping them become successful. (Table 6.)Table 6: Generational characteristicsBaby boomers tend to define professionalism primarily in the number of hours worked and one's dedication to the job. Generation X and millennials focus on personal lifestyle and balance, and do not have the same “workaholic” drive, creating the potential for intergenerational conflicts.9,10 Teachers can reduce conflict and facilitate learning by focusing on the positive aspects of each cohort, by fostering an atmosphere of respect, and by trying to understand generational perspectives.11 Most of the students currently in audiology programs are millennials, and teachers must temper their tendency to cut corners. (Table 7.)Table 7: Suggestions for teaching millennialsWhile working with today's audiology students can present challenges, understanding the learning process and the nature of the adult learner can enhance the effectiveness of teaching. The end result will then be a source of great professional and personal reward for you and your students. Missed parts 1 and 2? Read them by accessing these links on thehearingjournal.com: The Fundamentals (http://bit.ly/PreceptorPart1) and The Clinic as Classroom (http://bit.ly/PreceptorPart2).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lesner et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: