Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Our Trust uses the British Oxygen Company (Surrey Research Park, Guildford, Surrey, UK) CD lightweight portable oxygen cylinder with integral Combilite ‘click-stop’ regulator. These cylinders are used for patient transfers in all hospital areas. In January 2009 we found that one of these oxygen cylinders had a faulty regulator. The cylinder only delivered oxygen when the dial was set to a position between the dial numbers. Theatre staff had already noticed that the regulator dial must be turned accurately to the appropriate number for oxygen flow. In this instance, there was no flow when the required flow rate was selected accurately, but flow occurred at an intermediate position between the dial numbers. Soon after, a second cylinder with the same fault was identified. Both were returned to our pharmacy department. The MHRA was informed. We examined 46 of these cylinders using a calibrated flowmeter to check actual flow with the dial positions at 2, 4, 6 and 12 L.min−1. We recorded the approximate fill of the cylinders and whether the regulator dial functioned appropriately. All the regulators in this sample functioned i.e. when a number was dialed, oxygen flowed. There was no relationship between flow rates and cylinder pressure. Regulator accuracy varied. Of the 46 cylinders, 15 were accurate at all flow rates. Ten were accurate at 2–6 l.min−1 but delivered between 11 and 13 l.min−1 at a setting of 12 l.min−1. A further 14 were accurate at 2–4 L.min−1 but deviated from the flowmeter settings of 6 l.min−1 by 1–2 l.min−1. Of the remaining seven, five consistently under delivered by up to 25% of dialed setting (minimum flow rate of 1.5 l.min−1 at 2 l.min−1 setting; and 10 l.min−1 at 12 l.min−1 setting). Two over delivered by up to 25% of dialed setting; maximum actual flow of 14 l.min−1 at a 12 l.min−1 setting. These results confirm that the click-stop flowmeters are not completely accurate, but we consider the deviations insignificant in clinical use. Our main concern remains the original finding of two faulty cylinders. Failure of oxygen delivery can be easily overlooked because of the design of these new cylinders and regulators. The cylinder contents gauge is always functioning, indicating the internal cylinder pressure whether the cylinder is switched on or off. This is in contrast to the previously supplied cylinders where the gauge was distal to the regulator valve and only indicated a pressure when the cylinder was turned on. This has caused confusion amongst anaesthetic staff who note that there is adequate pressure on the gauge confirming oxygen in the cylinder, but are unaware that oxygen will not flow unless the cylinder is also turned on. The absence of a flowmeter has also removed a visual clue confirming oxygen flow. If the cylinder empties in transit, the only visual indication is the empty pressure gauge which may not be easily seen. Staff are now encouraged to listen for oxygen flow from the cylinder before attaching the oxygen mask to the patient. As usual, the important message is that there should be adequate familiarisation with any new equipment before introduction into the clinical environment.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
McVey et al. (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: