Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In conclusion a brief summary of the facts and considerations here presented will be useful. 1. In Oenothera the heterotypic mitosis is a reduction division, separating whole chromosomes which lie successively on the spirem. The homotypic mitosis is an equation division, separating the longitudinal halves of the daughter chromosomes of the heterotypic mitosis. Whether an approximation of threads or a split in a single thread occurs in synapsis was not determined with certainty from the observations, but various considerations lead to the belief that in Oenothera the doubling is due to a split which closes up later, rather than to an approximation of separate spirems. 2. The conclusion that the method of reduction probably differs in different genera is based on two considerations: (1) the fact that in most of the recent accounts of synapsis and reduction in plants a side-by-side pairing of chromosomes from maternal and paternal spirems is described, while in Oenothera the members of a pair are arranged end to end on a single spirem; and (2) on differences in chromosome distribution during reduction in certain hybrids of Drosera and of Oenothera (see p. 25). If reduction took place in the same manner in both genera, the chromosome distribution during reduction in these hybrids with reference to the parental chromosome numbers should be the same in both, but this is not the case. 3. Pairing between the definitive chromosomes during diakinesis and the prophase of the heterotypic mitosis does not always take place, owing to a weak attraction between the chromosomes. This allows irregularities of distribution in the heterotypic mitosis, so that both (unpaired) chromosomes belonging to one pair will occasionally enter the same daughter nucleus (see p. 26). Germ cells will thus arise, from which both members of a given pair of chromosomes are absent. 4. If we assume qualitative differences between the chromosomes or parts of them, various types would be expected to originate in this manner, each of them lacking the ability to develop certain qualities possessed by the parent form. On this view the mutations of Oenothera Lamarckiana are an instance of a process of analysis by which from the parent form arises a series of types, each lacking in certain characters or capacities possessed by the parent. This hypothesis would account for the absence of reversions among Oenothera mutants, and perhaps also for some of the peculiarities of hybridization in Oenothera. This matter will be considered at another time. This explanation does not apply to all the mutants, however; for example, O. gigas. 5. It is suggested that there is probably a direct relation between the events of reduction in a given genus and its variation, as well as its hybridization phenomena.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
R. Ruggles Gates (1908) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: