Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Objective. To provide an overview of journal-level metrics of Plastic Surgery (PS) journals (PSJs) by 1-year journal impact factor (2021JIF), total citations (TCs), and number of issues per year (NIYs) related to publishing models and publication costs for the authors.Methods. Cross-sectional bibliometric analysis of PS indexed peer-reviewed journals. Collected data were 2021JIF, TCs, NIY, and full Open Access (OA), Subscription-based, Hybrid models by Journal Citation Reports (JCR) 2021 directory (Web of Science), NIH catalogue (Medline), EMBASE, Directory of Open Access journals (DOAJ), journals’ websites. Descriptive statistics, correlation indexes (r) among 2021JIFs, TCs, NIYs, and APCs calculated by Microsoft Excel for Mac (version 16.16.27), XLSTAT statistical software for parametric tests (t-test); the cell value under 5% considered significant. The main outcome measure was the correlation between 2021JIFs, TCs, NIYs, and APCs. Results. Hybrid model present in 72.09%, full OA in 16.27% full OA, and Subscription-based in 13.95% of the PS journals. Mean APC of Hybrid was significantly higher than OA (p = 0.022) and Subscription- based (p = 0.007) models. There was no significant difference between mean 2021JIFs of Hybrid and full OA (p = 0.205), and Subscription- based (p = 0.245) models; no positive correlation between APCs and 2021JIFs [r = 0.35 in the full OA, r = 0.25 in the Hybrid, and r = 0.29 in the Subscription-based subgroups]; slight correlation between NIYs and APCs in the full OA and Hybrid subgroups. Median APC of the Hybrid (€ 3.010) was 56% more than the full OA model (€ 1.325); 17/43 (39.53%) journals offer waivers. Conclusions. The Hybrid was the prevalent model over full OA and Subscription-based, had higher APCs but not significantly different 2021JIFs. The choice of the journal upon which to publish should ground on BAs, contents’ quality, consistency with the intents of the scientific boards, methods of peer-reviewing, and transparent information of the publishers.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Amouzou et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: