Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The rehabilitation of forest and other woody vegetation ecosystems on mineral extraction sites is common place and a major post-mining land use throughout Australia. Owing to the need for government certification (under Australian and State legislation specified completion criteria which are indicative of rehabilitation goals are or have been achieved) there is often referral to and comparison with reference native vegetation sites. Examples of the ways in which reference sites have been selected and their limitations are considered in relation to some published examples for the rehabilitation of mineral sand, coal and bauxite surface mines in Queensland and Western Australia. Reference sites have been used for mainly setting mine closure land uses and vegetation types and the evaluation of the success of schemes. The identification and selection of reference sites requires rigour and justification according to the purpose and context of the comparisons being made. Importantly, the selection and sampling protocols need to be clearly set out and justified rather than, for example, simply stating number and sizes of plots used. This is particularly importance with respect to the bias introduced as the methodology used determines both the outcome and interpretation of the comparison being made. Greater consideration of the above might result in reference sites being more 'fit for purpose' than apparently might be the case. Another issue relating to the identification and selection of reference sites and their attributes as metrics for evaluation purposes is the matter of their state and condition. The use of mature reference stands rather than similar states to the immature rehabilitated stands needs to be factored in when selecting sites and interpreting the outcomes. In this context the recently suggested CARGIE model might be applied and developed further.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
R. N. Humphries (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: