Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Detection of non-stand-replacing disturbances is becoming highly important for forest monitoring. Methods to detect severe, stand-replacing disturbances are increasingly mature. On the other hand, non-stand-replacing (NSR) disturbances, though less severe, may cover large forest areas and thus pose an important monitoring problem, yet they remain difficult to detect in optical satellite image time series. The often very subtle change signals can usually be detected only for a brief time period, and the signal is often obscured by noise. In this study, we tested three detection algorithms that consider abruptness of and prior information about spectral changes to varying degrees. These detectors, in combination with a Kalman filter, were applied to detect both stand-replacing and NSR anthropogenic forest disturbances in six study sites throughout Finland. Clearcuts and heavy thinnings were easily detected without application of advanced detectors, but low intensity thinnings were detectable only by using both prior information and the assumption that changes are abrupt. The best detector achieved an F1-score of 0.72 for thinnings detection, compared to <0.6 for other detectors as well as the Stochastic Continuous Change Detection (S-CCD) method and the European Forest Disturbance Atlas (EFDA). In clearcuts, the three detectors we tested performed equally well as S-CCD and EFDA. The results indicate the potential of using an informative Bayesian approach in detecting NSR disturbances with optical satellite image time series.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Schraik et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: