Key result
Primary prosthetic replacement yielded 79% excellent or good results at 1 year compared to 55% for internal fixation, but was 1.6 times more expensive in total costs.
Why the study?
Does internal fixation compared to primary prosthetic replacement reduce costs and hospital resource consumption in elderly patients with femoral neck fractures?
Cohort
Does internal fixation compared to primary prosthetic replacement reduce costs and hospital resource consumption in elderly patients with femoral neck fractures?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
While primary prosthetic replacement for femoral neck fractures in the elderly yields better 1-year clinical results than internal fixation, it is associated with 1.6 times higher total costs.
The consumption of hospital resources and the costs involved in treating femoral neck fractures in the elderly were studied and a comparison was made between internal fixation (von Bahr screws) and primary prosthetic replacement (Christiansen's endoprosthesis). The 1-year results of screw fixation were excellent or good in 55% of the patients, fair in 17% and poor in 28%, compared with 79% excellent or good results, 13% fair and 8% poor results in the prosthetic group. As regards the initial stay in hospital, prosthetic replacement was found to be associated with 2.4 times higher costs. This difference was reduced, however, by a more expensive follow-up and more frequent readmissions and reoperations in the internal fixation group. Considering the total costs, prosthetic replacement was found to be 1.6 times more expensive than internal fixation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Söreide et al. (1980) conducted a cohort in Femoral neck fractures. Primary prosthetic replacement vs. Internal fixation was evaluated on Excellent or good results. Primary prosthetic replacement yielded 79% excellent or good results at 1 year compared to 55% for internal fixation, but was 1.6 times more expensive in total costs.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: