Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Mixed-methods network analysis finds digital participation tools coexist with affective barriers in university students, highlighting the need for low-risk, multimodal participation design.
Technology-supported classrooms can broaden access to learning, but access does not ensure inclusive voice. This study examined behind-the-screen silence as an affective-participatory experience among Chinese university students in courses with digital or hybrid components. Survey data were obtained from 423 respondents; after range checking and exclusion of straightline responses, the strict analytic sample included 375 students. Twenty-two exploratory classroom-silence items were analyzed using descriptive statistics, one-factor measurement diagnostics, an ordinal item-level network, teaching-mode sensitivity checks, VIF diagnostics, auxiliary regression, and thematic coding of 168 open-ended responses. The one-factor model showed acceptable approximate fit, indicating a strong general silence-related tendency. The primary network was dense but showed modest local associations among technology-pedagogy constraints, digital response affordances, online silence, and affective insecurity; an alternative-estimator sensitivity check produced a highly similar edge-weight pattern. Teaching-mode comparisons suggested small domain differences and advised caution because the online-dominant subgroup was small. Domain correlations were high, but VIF values did not indicate severe multicollinearity; regression was therefore treated only as auxiliary association evidence, with affective barriers showing the largest standardized association. Independent recoding of 30.4% of open-text responses showed high agreement (92.2%; Cohen's kappa = 0.909). Overall, digital participation tools appeared to coexist with unresolved affective, interactional, and recognition-related barriers, identifying low-risk, responsive, and multimodal participation as design priorities for future classroom evaluation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Liu et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: