Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Increase in marijuana potency is a logical step in the process of transforming an illegal product into a commodity. Another step is marketing, aimed at transforming marijuana into a mainstream product for mass consumption. Smart et al. 1 analyzes the Washington State retail market and documents the disappearance of marijuana flowers with lower tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) content and market share increase of very potent marijuana extracts. This commentary contextualizes this finding as one of the many changes occurring to marijuana after the passage of a market-oriented legalization in Washington State. As marijuana makes the transition from an illegal substance into a profitable commodity, it has evolved as a product and has been repositioned as a consumption item for the masses through marketing and advertisement. The transformation of the ‘traditional weed’ into high-potency marijuana is an illustration of the market's quest for efficiency through product development. In the case of marijuana, efficiency equals higher intoxication properties. Other changes also in process include higher portability (as in the case of extracts), convenience (pre-rolled joints) and discretion (vaporizers with no smell 2). For the marijuana industry to thrive, products need to be purchased; current users need to use more; and new consumers need to come on board. In Washington, marijuana-related paid advertisements and marijuana-specific marketing agencies have skyrocketed since legalization 3-5. Business-oriented publications recommend mainstreaming marijuana use through advertisement: ‘To avoid turning off a lucrative audience, avoid stoner slang and overly pot-centric visuals. Instead, opt for modern designs, sleek fonts and a clearer brand voice to carry your message to the most diverse audience possible’ 6. Marketing agencies assist clients to associate marijuana with life-styles through imagery that promotes brand connection: ‘Cannabrand designs typically use lifestyle-oriented images: young people hiking, frolicking with friends, or sitting around campfires’ 3. In advertisements focused on product features, adjectives describing quality and purity dominate. A pilot analysis of Dope Magazine 2, a free marijuana-focused magazine directed to consumers, found that marijuana concentrates’ advertisements abundantly use words such as ‘twice refined’, ‘clean’, ‘nothing artificial’, ‘ultra-purified’ and ‘ultra-premium’. Interestingly, evidence to date suggests that these attributes are far from applicable to these products 7. What does this tell public health researchers? It tells us we need to catch up. Washington State marijuana businesses’ investment in product innovation and marketing is outpacing society's capacity to comprehend the implications of these changes, and to enact evidence-based regulations to protect vulnerable populations. We need equal investment in public health research, from marijuana state collected excise taxes, as it was promised to Washington State voters. To date, US$690 000 dollars has been allocated to research, of the almost half-billion generated in excise taxes since legalization 8. The two recipients of these funds—state universities—cannot answer many pressing questions with this meagre resource. For instance, research is needed to determine the impact of community-based initiatives on social and health outcomes 9. In Washington State, 125 municipalities and 30 counties have passed ordinances restricting marijuana sales at some level 9. As of June 2016, 30% of the Washington State population lived in places that had temporarily or permanently banned retail sales, due to a non-pre-emptive state law. This is a unique real-world opportunity that needs to be leveraged for policy research. Current marijuana advertising regulations do not seem to be enough, and researchers can work with state regulators to support sound restrictions. Decades of tobacco and alcohol marketing research offers some insights into what might happen without stringent regulations. Tobacco advertising exposure is associated with onset of and continued tobacco consumption in a dose-dependent fashion, especially among minors 5-7. Alcohol advertisement exposure is associated longitudinally with early onset of alcohol use and heavy consumption among youth and minorities 10-12. Studies about the impact of product development on consumer behavior are needed urgently. Tobacco was not as addictive and lethal in the 1800s as it is today. Contemporary tobacco became highly addictive and deadly as a result of a series of product developments made by the nascent tobacco industry in the 1900s 13. Milder tobacco blends and new curing processes allowed deeper inhalation and higher absorption of nicotine, added chemicals enhanced absorption and taste and new machines introduced a pre-rolled cigarette, packaged perfectly and shaped as cylinders 13. This cautionary tale should give us pause when using pre-legalization studies to calculate marijuana's addictive potential—new studies need to be conducted. Washington State residents were lured by the marijuana legalization movement's social justice and anti-stigma rhetoric. In our desire to correct the injustices marijuana prohibition generated, we came to believe that we had only two options: against or in favor of full-blown legalization. Middle-ground options that could have addressed the main concerns of those in favor of lifting prohibition were somehow lost in the shuffle 14, 15. History cannot be undone. It is time to regroup, rethink and produce new knowledge that supports evidence-based policy to protect collective health from the challenges posed by the adoption of a corporate-based marijuana legalization in the state of Washington and elsewhere. None. Funded by the Marijuana Dedicated Fund for Research at the University of Washington Alcohol & Drug Abuse Institute.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Beatriz H. Carlini (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: