Key result
Artificial neural networks and Volterra models achieved comparable normalized mean-square error in predicting renal autoregulation, though Volterra models required approximately half the free parameters.
Volterra models and artificial neural networks are both effective for modeling nonlinear dynamic systems like renal autoregulation, though Volterra models may be more parameter-efficient.
Animal data favor parameter-efficient Volterra models for renal autoregulation; leaves open translation to human cardiovascular research.
Volterra models have been increasingly popular in modeling studies of nonlinear physiological systems. In this paper, feedforward artificial neural networks with two types of activation functions (sigmoidal and polynomial) are utilized for modeling the nonlinear dynamic relation between renal blood pressure and flow data, and their performance is compared to Volterra models obtained by use of the leading kernel estimation method based on Laguerre expansions. The results for the two types of artificial neural networks (sigmoidal and polynomial) and the Volterra models are comparable in terms of normalized mean-square error (NMSE) of the respective output prediction for independent testing data. However, the Volterra models obtained via the Laguerre expansion technique achieve this prediction NMSE with approximately half the number of free parameters relative to either neural-network model. Nonetheless, both approaches are deemed effective in modeling nonlinear dynamic systems and their cooperative use is recommended in general, since they may exhibit different strengths and weaknesses depending on the specific characteristics of each application.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Chon et al. (1998) studied Renal autoregulation. Artificial neural networks (sigmoidal and polynomial) vs. Volterra models (Laguerre expansions) was evaluated on Normalized mean-square error (NMSE) of output prediction. Artificial neural networks and Volterra models achieved comparable normalized mean-square error in predicting renal autoregulation, though Volterra models required approximately half the free parameters.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: