Key result
Radiography is more sensitive than physical examination and more generally useful than electrocardiography for measuring cardiac size in rheumatic heart disease.
Why the study?
How does radiologic evaluation compare to physical examination and electrocardiography for assessing heart size in patients with rheumatic heart disease?
How does radiologic evaluation compare to physical examination and electrocardiography for assessing heart size in patients with rheumatic heart disease?
Radiography is considered more sensitive than physical examination and more generally useful than electrocardiography for assessing heart size in rheumatic heart disease, despite subjective quantitation and physiologic variations.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports radiography for heart size in rheumatic heart disease over exam or ECG; leaves open relevance versus modern imaging.
The determination of heart size is essential for ' evaluating prognosis and the need for physical limitations after an acute attack of rheumatic fever. Of the available simple techniques for measuring cardiac size, radiography is more sensitive than physical examination and is, in rheumatic heart disease, more generally useful than electrocardiography. However, radiologic examination of the heart has certain major disadvantages: (1) Measurements of the cardiac silhouette may often be affected by physiologic factors and do not provide a sharp demarcation between normal and abnormal; (2) quantitation of chamber size is done subjectively, and (3) fluoroscopy, which is usually considered better than films for assessing the effects of respiration or of cardiac contraction, is undesirable because of the need for increased radiation1,2and the lack of a permanent record. Despite these disadvantages, radiography continues to be the major clinical technique for appraisal of heart size. The present work was done
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Julian Frieden (1963) studied Rheumatic Heart Disease. Radiography vs. Physical examination and electrocardiography was evaluated. Radiography is more sensitive than physical examination and more generally useful than electrocardiography for measuring cardiac size in rheumatic heart disease.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: