Key result
Preoperative morphological classification of inferior vena cava tumor thrombus into type I and type II in 156 patients with renal cell carcinoma showed a significant difference in thrombus height.
Why the study?
Does preoperative morphology of IVC thrombus predict prognosis in RCC patients?
Does preoperative morphology of IVC thrombus predict prognosis in RCC patients?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Preoperative morphological classification of IVC thrombus may serve as a novel prognostic factor for RCC patients, though further prospective validation is required.
The article by Choi et al. addresses the impact of morphological characteristics of the inferior vena cava (IVC) tumor thrombus of renal cell carcinoma (RCC) on clinicopathological features including overall survival and cancer-specific survival.1 We often experience cases of RCC patients with IVC thrombus whose indication of surgical treatment is controversial. As the authors discussed, previous studies have reported several parameters, such as clinical tumor size, histological subtype, the status of distant metastasis, body mass index and performance status, for predicting the prognosis in RCC patients with IVC thrombus.2-5 In addition to these parameters, the condition of the thrombus, such as its level and sites, should be considered because they are thought to be associated with the postoperative prognosis in each patient. It is very informative and beneficial for urological surgeons to demonstrate a new parameter for predicting the prognosis of RCC patients with IVC thrombus, “preoperative morphology of IVC thrombus,” besides parameters previously reported.6-8 In the study by Choi et al., 156 RCC patients with IVC thrombus were classified into two groups, type I and type II, on the basis of the preoperative morphological characteristics of IVC thrombus on imaging examination.1 There was a statistically significant difference in thrombus height between the cases with type I thrombi and those with type II thrombi. Although the impact of the extension of IVC thrombus on the oncological outcome after surgical resection remains controversial, it is a very important point to discuss. Possible associations between histological findings with such a morphological difference of IVC thrombus are also interesting. However, which mechanism leads to the morphological difference of IVC thrombus and the reason why the morphology of IVC thrombus is associated with the prognosis of RCC patients remain unclear. Further studies with a larger volume are expected to investigate and clarify these points in the future. One important theme of the morphological classification in the present study is whether the imaging examination findings are reproducible. The priority between computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging findings needs to be clarified to prevent confusion from possible discrepancies in them. Although representative findings for each group were shown in figures, we might experience cases of RCC with IVC thrombus whose morphology are difficult to clearly classify. The criteria of this morphological classification need to be more sophisticated and clearer in the future in order to make them more useful in real clinical practice. The present study is expected to be an important step in establishing a novel risk stratification for RCC patients with IVC thrombus, although there were some limitations because of the retrospective and multi-institutional design. Further investigations with a prospective and randomized design are required to confirm such a model. None declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jun Teishima (2017) conducted an editorial in Renal cell carcinoma with inferior vena cava tumor thrombus (n=156). Preoperative morphology of IVC thrombus (type I vs type II) vs. Type I vs Type II was evaluated on Thrombus height. Preoperative morphological classification of inferior vena cava tumor thrombus into type I and type II in 156 patients with renal cell carcinoma showed a significant difference in thrombus height.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: