Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Competency in diagnostic and therapeutic endoscopy implies a demonstration of appropriate clinical judgment in patient selection and adequate cognitive and technical skills to complete a procedure safely and successfully. The endoscopist must have knowledge of appropriate indications and contraindications for each procedure and a full appreciation of the potential risks and benefits. The endoscopist must also be capable of communicating effectively with patients and families so that informed consent can be obtained and results of the procedure explained. Finally, the physician must be prepared personally to manage or to enlist the help of others to manage complications or adverse outcomes expeditiously in an appropriate medical facility. The American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ASGE) has identified six primary objectives for training in gastrointestinal endoscopy(Table 1) that address these issues(1). Certain cognitive (e.g., lesion recognition) and technical (e.g., successful cecal intubation) aspects of competency can be readily assessed in quantifiable terms, to facilitate a critical evaluation of current training and credentialing requirements. Because diagnostic and therapeutic procedures pose immediate risks to patients and may dramatically alter their medical care, procedural competency and outcomes should be subject to close scrutiny. Gastrointestinal endoscopy comprises the bulk of procedures conducted by a pediatric gastroenterologist and is the focus of this commentary. Clinical competency in other procedures, including percutaneous liver biopsy, manometry, rectal or other nonendoscopic biopsy, endosonography, and laparoscopy, will not be discussed here. Cognitive Skills Competency in pediatric endoscopy requires a specialized knowledge of gastrointestinal diseases affecting children. Such knowledge is conventionally gained through formal training in pediatric gastroenterology. However, other physicians experienced in the care of children or adults with gastrointestinal disease (pediatric surgeons or adult gastroenterologists), may acquire suitable cognitive skills to achieve competency in pediatric endoscopy(2). Supervision Endoscopy trainees require supervision by a competent pediatric endoscopist while building technical skills. The degree or extent of supervision may be adjusted as these skills mature. The 1992 ASGE training guidelines(1) highlight three stages of endoscopic training. Stage I-the stage of complete supervision during which indications, contraindications, and sedation practices are carefully reviewed and handling of the endoscope by the trainee is gradually increased. Stage II-the stage at which partial supervision is necessary, with the teacher intervening only when difficulties are encountered. Stage III-the stage at which a trainee has been declared competent to perform a particular procedure and no longer requires direct supervision, yet may at times request assistance or advice for unusual findings or difficult procedures. Despite a declaration of competence, current reimbursement and risk management regulations often require continued supervision of trainees by an attending physician until formal certification has occurred and institutional privileges have been granted. For example, in the case of Medicare patients, current U. S. Government Health Care Finance Administration regulations require that the teaching physician be present for the entire endoscopic viewing to qualify for reimbursement (3). The same regulations will probably be applied to Medicaid patients and adopted by other medical insurance programs. Thresholds for Assessing Competency For any trainee, the rapidity with which competency is achieved depends on three factors: native talents or such abilities as visual pattern recognition, hand-eye coordination, and manual dexterity; quality of instruction; and extent of experience. The relative contribution of the first two factors to acquisition of competency is difficult to assess quantitatively. The correlation of acquired skill to number of procedures performed, however, can be objectively examined. The 1992 ASGE training guidelines (1) recommend a threshold of numbers of procedures that should be performed in patients before competency can be assessed (Table 2). These numbers represent a consensus opinion based on the experience of a committee of expert endoscopists who were, in fact, divided with regard to the actual number of procedures a trainee should perform to attain competence(4). Although the threshold numbers were initially criticized as too high, results of subsequent studies have not only validated the need for high thresholds but have indicated that even the recommended thresholds are too low (4). In a retrospective analysis in 1992, Parry and Williams (5) found that trainees did not attain a consistent 90% completion rate for colonoscopy until they had performed 200 procedures. Results of a single-center prospective study by Cass et al. (6) demonstrated a cecal intubation rate by trainees of only 84% after 100 colonoscopic procedures, whereas staff reached the cecum a mean of 94% of the time. Individual trainees did not achieve this success rate until after performing more than 200 colonoscopies. Similarly, a success rate of more than 90% was not achieved with esophagogastroduodenoscopy(EGD) until trainees had completed more than 100 procedures(Fig. 1). After 100 procedures, the mean time for trainees to perform EGD was 22 minutes (range, 13-31 minutes) and to perform colonoscopy, 55 minutes (range, 11-99 minutes). Recognition of abnormal findings during endoscopy was more than 85% initially and did not change with increasing experience. A major limitation of this study was the relatively small number of trainees (n = 12) evaluated. Chak et al.(7) reported results in a single-center prospective study in which trainees could not attain a 90% cecal completion rate, after an average of 120 colonoscopies. The average success rate of the teaching staff was 94.3% in a median time of 10.5 minutes. To date, the largest multicenter prospective study of acquisition of endoscopy skill involved 243 mentors evaluating 135 trainees in 14 training programs. Trainees were evaluated during a total of 11,213 EGDs and 6,889 colonoscopies. The findings were presented by Cass at the 1996 annual meeting of the ASGE(8). The results again demonstrated that the average trainee needed more than 130 EGDs and 140 colonoscopies to complete the examination 90% of the time (Fig. 2). Although endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) is infrequently used in pediatric patients, assessment of skill acquisition for this procedure in adult patients shows a similar trend. Jowell et al.(9) recently showed that trainees (n = 17) required more than 180 ERCPs to achieve an acceptable score for deep cannulation of the bile duct, with a probability of 80%. Predicted probabilities of achieving an acceptable overall score for ERCP were 80% after 137 ERCPs and 90% after 185 ERCPs. Watkins et al. (10) prospectively evaluated the performance of 21 trainees in a single institution for up to 100 procedures. Competence was defined by a success rate equal to or higher than 85% for either selective pancreatography or cholangiography. Such competence was attained in selective pancreatography after 70 procedures but was not attained in selective bile duct cannulation by 100 procedures. Selective deep cannulation of the bile duct is a skill necessary for the conduct of many therapeutic interventions. Results reported in all of the above studies suggest that the current ASGE recommendations for thresholds based on procedure number are inadequate to prepare the average trainee for certifiable competence. In recognition of this problem, the ASGE Training and Education Committee has begun the process of revising these guidelines (J. Van Dam, personal communication, September 1997). Thresholds for Competency in Pediatric Endoscopy As the subspecialty field of pediatric gastroenterology has grown and matured, pediatric endoscopy has become a routine part of patient care and has been integrated into most training programs. Yet, expertise in pediatric endoscopy has emerged slowly, impeded by small case numbers, limitations in suitable equipment, and lack of rigorous training standards. The Training and Education Committee of the North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition (NASPGN) has addressed the subject of training requirements for pediatric endoscopy in a position paper published recently in this journal (11). The NASPGN document reinforces basic principles outlined in the current ASGE training guidelines and stresses the need for a qualified endoscopy training director to oversee endoscopy training in each pediatric program. The NASPGN guidelines differ from the ASGE guidelines on the procedure threshold numbers (Table 2). The most notable difference is a lower threshold number for colonoscopy in the NASPGN guidelines. Thresholds for several therapeutic procedures are also lower in the pediatric guidelines. An exception is the change of category from standard procedure to advanced procedure for nonvariceal hemostasis. Although no explanation for the difference in threshold numbers is provided, it is likely that the reduced numbers represent a compromise between factions favoring no threshold numbers and those favoring higher numbers, which would be difficult, if not impossible, to attain during the course of most pediatric gastroenterology training programs. However, a recommendation for lower threshold numbers implies that endoscopy is either easier to perform successfully in children than in adult patients or that a lower level of competence or a lower completion rate is acceptable when performing endoscopy in children. Until there is evidence that endoscopy in children requires less skill or experience than is needed for examining adult patients, similar threshold standards should apply to both. Certainly, a lower level of competence is undesirable and cannot be advocated. Because results of prospective evaluation of adult endoscopy trainees consistently indicate that higher-than-expected threshold numbers are required to achieve competence, defined as equal to or more than 90% success in EGD and colonoscopy and 80-85% success in ERCP, pediatric endoscopists should take the lead in setting equally rigorous standards of training for specialists who care for children. Although threshold numbers reflect the “average” trainee's experience, skill acquisition for a trainee should also be tracked, using subjective and objective measures. Certification and Privileges Certification is the process by which a trainee is judged competent by an arbitrary set of standards after minimum requirements (e.g., threshold procedure numbers) have been met. The 1992 ASGE training guidelines acknowledged that “Objective standardized criteria of trainee (and training program) competence are desirable but presently not available” and that “lacking accurate measures of overall proficiency in GI procedures, certification of procedure-specific competence is best determined by an experienced training director with knowledge of technical, clinical, and personal factors.” Absolute standards of competence are arbitrary and may vary between training directors and training programs. For example, one training director may decide that competency in colonoscopy requires a success rate of 85% or more of cecal intubation, whereas another director requires a success rate equal to or more than 95%. Trainees acquire skills at different rates. Some trainees may become certifiably competent after relatively few procedure; others may never master certain skills. Ideally, training programs should apply uniform and rigorous standards before competency is certified. A demonstration of competence immediately after completion of a formal training program does not ensure continued competence in a given procedure. In general, skills and competence grow with cumulative experience. However, some technical skills (e.g., therapeutic ERCP) may also require frequent practice to maintain proficiency and familiarity with changing technology. In 1995, the ASGE published a position statement that broadly addressed the issue of maintaining competency in endoscopic skills, without recommending specific procedure numbers or frequencies (12). Intermittent proctoring or supervision by another certified endoscopist was encouraged. Privilege to conduct procedures is granted by individual health-care facilities (13). This decision should take into account whether an endoscopist has had formal training and has met recommended guidelines for assessment of competence. Referring clinicians and patients should have access to information about the level of training and experience of the endoscopist. The granting of privileges should also require a direct demonstration of competence before an impartial proctoring endoscopist. Given the limited number of endoscopy cases encountered by a pediatric trainee during a standard clinical training period, minimum thresholds for certain procedures may not be reached. Certification of competence in these procedures should be postponed until minimum thresholds have been reached during advanced training (14). Current pediatric training programs may have to be redesigned to include more extensive endoscopy experience if certifiable competence is sought for a full range of procedures. Pediatric Competence: Problems and Solutions The above data and recommendations present several problems for pediatric training programs and practicing pediatric gastroenterologists. For example, some training programs may not have an expert pediatric endoscopist. Many programs have too few procedures for a trainee to meet minimum threshold numbers for even such standard procedures as colonoscopy. A pediatric endoscopist with excellent basic skills but limited experience with advanced therapeutic interventions may face a clinical situation in which a patient would benefit from urgent endoscopic therapy but the endoscopist lacks experience with the needed technique (e.g., endoscopic hemostasis for active bleeding from a visible vessel in an ulcer). How can the pediatric endoscopist gain the necessary procedure experience and simultaneously provide optimal care to the patient? Pediatric gastroenterology training programs that are credentialed by the American Board of Pediatrics or an equivalent body should be required to have a designated endoscopy training director who is an expert endoscopist. The background subspecialty of such an individual (pediatric vs. adult gastroenterologist vs. surgeon) is less important than the technical and cognitive skills brought to that position. Most endoscopists trained exclusively in pediatrics require more advanced training in the form of extended fellowship training (14), hands-on courses(15), and on-the-job supervision by an expert adult endoscopist to achieve a high level of expertise. Training programs in which low numbers of procedures are performed may have to reduce the number of trainees, extend the training period, or share procedures with other programs so that trainees can attain minimum thresholds. Endoscopy simulation training devices, which were first introduced in 1986, have been developed in prototype for EGD, colonoscopy, sigmoidoscopy, and ERCP(16). These computer-based simulators may reduce the need for patient-based training in the future. Animal models also offer an alternative to patient-based endoscopy training. For example, the intact porcine model is currently preferred for practicing diagnostic and therapeutic ERCP (17) and has been used for the recent ASGE-sponsored hands-on courses in ERCP and endosonography. A freshly excised pig stomach with attached esophagus and duodenum may be used for teaching routine upper gastrointestinal endoscopy and interventional methods, including sclerotherapy and other hemostasis techniques (18). When any endoscopist faces a situation in which endoscopic intervention may benefit the patient but personal experience is lacking, every effort should be made to find expert assistance. Alternative therapies should be strongly considered, depending on the severity of potential complications. The patient and family should be informed of the endoscopist's level of training and experience so that the risks and benefits can be carefully weighed and informed consent can be obtained. Endoscopic procedures that are infrequently practiced by pediatric endoscopists and carry substantial risk of severe complications (e.g. therapeutic ERCP) should perhaps never be performed without some level of supervision by a more expert endoscopist. Acknowledgment: The author thanks Drs. David L. Carr-Locke and Jacques Van Dam, Director and Associate Director of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy at Brigham and Women's Hospital for their critical review of this manuscript and their commitment to advancing the field of pediatric endoscopy. This article is adapted from a lecture presented at the 1997 16th Annual Seminar on Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition jointly sponsored by Ross Products and the North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition.FIG. 1: . Percentage of success in intubating each area during the previous 10 procedures, related to the number of procedures performed. Data are mean values with 95% confidence intervals for all trainees evaluated during that training period. (Reprinted, with permission, from Cass et al.,Ann Intern Med 1993;118:40-4.)FIG. 2: . Global percentage of success during esophagogastroduodenoscopy and colonoscopy for 135 trainees in a 14-member multicenter study assessing competence in endoscopic skills. (Reprinted, with permission, from Cass et al., Gastrointest Endosc 1996;43:308.)
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Victor L. Fox (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: