Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
K Hambly, AJ Muir. (201 pages, £19.99.) Butterworth-Heinemann, 1997. ISBN 0-7506-2737-9. The blurb on the back cover of this book concludes with the statement “Stress Management in Primary Care is an essential purchase for all General Practitioners”. This sentence epitomizes the problem that I have with the book as a whole. It is didactic, uncompromising and seems to leave no space for the possibility of an alternative view. I readily acknowledge the importance of recognizing the stress-related aspects of the complaints, symptoms and illness presented to the doctor in daily encounters with patients, encompassed in the adage about considering the ‘physical, psychological and social factors' of the patient's problem. But for me the almost exclusively behavioural approach of this book limits its usefulness as an overview of the important topic of stress, because I feel that undertaking to manage an individual patient's stress usually requires a broader basis for understanding its specific nature. (For example, a possible connection between the current stress and the patient's vulnerability, usually related to early adverse experience.) Nonetheless, there is much information in the book about factors contributing to stress in the lives of patients (and doctors), the symptoms to which this can give rise and the mechanisms whereby physiological factors contribute. A list of possible causes of workplace stress runs to nine headings and 58 items. The list of possible stress-related symptoms includes 20 physical, 12 psychological and 17 behavioural. (One problem of such an exhaustive list is that virtually anyone, ill or otherwise, could probably tick off a few—a fact which sells a good many self-help books to a credulous public by offering similar lists of symptoms and ascribing them to candida, food allergy, ME or some other currently fashionable concern.) Stress management is summarized under four headings: information and explanation; resolving the cause if possible; ‘cushioning’ the effects of stress; and changing how the person sees the situation. Management includes techniques for reducing autonomic arousal, relaxation and breathing, advice regarding lifestyle changes, and substituting better coping strategies for the bad ones which may be exacerbating the problems. There are useful appendices detailing the preparation of leaflets, cassettes and other informative material for patients, which could be used by the doctor or in a stress management clinic run by other practice staff. Any reference to the problem of depressive illness as such is omitted. While it is included within the general frame of reference, the specific diagnosis, management and treatment are barely mentioned. While some depressed patients may benefit from stress management techniques as described here, many more could fail to obtain either medication or more appropriate therapy by being lumped together into the ‘stress' category. So is this an essential purchase for all GPs? My view is that it would be valuable for someone thinking of setting up a stress management clinic, or for an inexperienced doctor approaching the topic for the first time, provided it is seen as telling only a part of the story and considered alongside other material which takes a wider approach.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marie Campkin (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: