Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
EXPERIMENTS in our laboratory, soon to be reported in the “American Journal of Cancer,” indicate that there is no direct stimulation of tissue grown in vitro by radium which causes an uncontrolled increase in the rate of mitotic division. Our clinical observations point to some alternative explanation, namely, an over-response by the tissue to a destructive or irritating action. This is consistent with the history of malignancy which developed from an over-exposure among the early radiologists, and is further suggested by the bone necrosis which has been found to occur when radium seeds, improperly screened, have been placed in the oral cavity. This necrosis does not appear as a rule until several years after the exposure. In neither instance is there any radioactive deposit in the body. The action is local and indicates that some element in the cell has been injured, the effect of which does not become apparent for some time. This latent action due to radiation is still unexplained. The evidence so far produced suggests that the action of radium does not follow the Arndt-Schultz law, namely, that large doses destroy and weak doses irritate. My observations, while growing tissue in vitro surrounded by a radio-active medium, leads me to believe that the action of radium is always destructive; that it is a matter of the chance impact of the alpha particle or gamma ray on some vital portion of the cell—probably the nucleus—which causes either theimmediate or a delayed death of the cell. The smaller the amount of radio-active deposit present, the less chance there is for this impact to take place within any certain time. This opinion is further strengthened by clinical observations. The same type of destruction takes place in our cases whether the deposit is large or small, and, furthermore, it becomes just as extensive with the passage of time. The irritation, which may be an etiologic factor in causing malignancy, is the result of the condition of the tissue brought about by the exposure rather than because of the direct irritating action of radium itself. The first case of radium poisoning that came under my direct supervision was in 1926. It was primarily a case of antral sinusitis and a necrotic involvement of the mandible, ending in general septicemia. In 1924, the patient, while dancing in her home, had suffered a spontaneous fracture of the femur which did not knit. At the time of our examination, the two ends of the fracture overlapped, and Were banded together by means of a silver ring. Because of our lack of knowledge, in 1926, as to the action of radium when deposited in the body, we did not believe that there was any connection between the fracture and her industrial exposure. The radiograph of the bone showed no pathologic lesions. At autopsy, no indications of malignancy were found at the area of fracture.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Frederick B. Flinn (1934) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: