Key result
A 15-minute guided relaxation program significantly reduced symptom distress in cancer patients, with an average 31% decrease in total ESAS score (P<.01), but did not change HRV HF power.
Why the study?
Does a 15-minute guided relaxation program improve symptom distress and heart rate variability in cancer patients?
Does a 15-minute guided relaxation program improve symptom distress and heart rate variability in cancer patients?
Effect estimate: 31% decrease
p-value: p=<.01
A brief 15-minute guided relaxation program significantly improves self-reported symptom distress in cancer patients, though it does not acutely alter heart rate variability.
May support brief relaxation for cancer symptom relief; leaves open HRV effects and requires RCTs before practice change.
OBJECTIVES: To determine whether a 15-minute, one-time guided relaxation program for cancer patients could improve symptom distress as measured by the Edmonton Symptom Assessment System (ESAS). In addition, we were interested in characterizing the changes of the autonomic nervous system, as demonstrated by heart rate variability (HRV) high-frequency (HF) spectral analysis, before and after this relaxation program. DESIGN: Nonrandomized pilot study. SETTING: Comprehensive cancer center. METHODS: Twenty cancer patients underwent a 15-minute relaxation program. The ESAS and a 5-minute HRV recording were completed before and after the relaxation program. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The differences between the pre- and post-summed ESAS score and HRV values were compared by a paired t-test. RESULTS: The summed ESAS scores were significantly lower after the relaxation program (P<.01), with an average 31% decrease in total score. However, no differences were found in HRV HF power. There was no correlation between the change in HRV HF and change in symptom distress, as measured by ESAS. CONCLUSIONS: A brief guided relaxation program can significantly improve symptoms as measured by ESAS. More research is required to understand the effects of relaxation on HF HRV power.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Asher et al. (2010) studied Cancer (n=20). Guided relaxation program vs. Pre-intervention baseline was evaluated on Symptom distress as measured by the Edmonton Symptom Assessment System (ESAS) and heart rate variability (HRV) high-frequency (HF) spectral analysis (31% decrease, p=<.01). A 15-minute guided relaxation program significantly reduced symptom distress in cancer patients, with an average 31% decrease in total ESAS score (P<.01), but did not change HRV HF power.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: