Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Symptom validity vesting (SVT), also known as forced-choice testing, is a means of assessing the validity of sensory and memory deficits, including tactile anesthesias, paresthesias, blindness, color blindness, tunnel vision, blurry vision and deafness.1,3,4,5 The common feature among all these symptoms is a claimed inability to perceive or remember a sensory signal. The adaptability of SVT to perceptual or memory complaints is limited only by the examiner—s imagination. SVT is not adaptable to evaluating claims of internal sensory signals (for example, pain).Symptom validity testing comprises two elements: (1) a specific ability is assessed by presenting a large number of items in a multiple-choice format, and (2) the examinee—s performance is compared to the statistical likelihood of success based on chance alone, (ie, no ability). These tests usually have two multiple-choice alternatives; thus, the probability of purely guessing the correct response (ie, analogous to no ability at all) is 50%. Scores significantly below chance performance indicate that the sensory cues must have been perceived, but that the examinee chose not to report the correct answer; alternative explanations are not apparent.6A coin toss is a familiar model of probability to explain this technique. For example, a blind person does not have the capacity necessary to perceive the sensory cues required to call heads or tails correctly, except at a chance rate. No scoring advantage is achieved by calling heads or tails in any pattern or order. Heads and tails are the only possible responses (two alternatives), and the task requires the examinee to make only one response (forced choice). In the case of total impairment, (ie, total blindness), performance should approximate chance responding (50% accuracy with a two-choice task). A significant deviation from chance responding is defined as an accuracy score with a probability less than some specified level (for example, p < 0.05 or p < 0.01) as determined by the binomial probability distribution. For example, from Table 1 (the standard statistical one-tailed probability of obtaining fewer than 40 correct responses in 100 trials with a two-choice task is less than 2% [p < 0.0179]). Achieving fewer than 36 correct answers would occur by chance fewer than 2 times in 1000 tests (p < 0.0019).This technique is easily adapted to assessing the validity of claimed sensory deficits. For example, an examinee reporting total sensory loss would not have the capacity necessary to perceive the sensory cues required to identify sharp or dull correctly except at a chance rate. Sharp and dull are the only possible responses (two alternatives) and the task requires the examinee to make only one response (forced choice). In the case of total sensory loss, performance should approximate chance responding. Similarly, two-point sensory discrimination can be evaluated using this technique; one and two points are the only possible reponses (two alternatives) and the examinee must choose one (forced choice). In these examples, presentation of the sensory cues is facilitated by using a table of random numbers.The positive predictive value of the symptom validity technique is likely to be quite high, because there is no alternate explanation to deliberate distortion when performance is below the probability of chance. The sensitivity of this technique, however, is not likely to be as good for a number of reasons: (1) many deceptive examinees do not claim a total deficit and, therefore, would not be expected to perform significantly below chance levels, (2) some deceptive examinees violate the rules of the technique. For example, they might avoid the signal cue, respond with a pattern, or repeat the same answer, all of which will ensure a 50% response rate. Consequently, this technique is analogous to a thermometer: positive findings indicate that a problem is present, but negative findings do not rule out the problem.Symptom validity testing provides an opportunity to show more than a low score. It also has the capacity to demonstrate that the examinee performed below the probabilities of chance. Scoring below a norm can be explained in many different ways (ie, fatigue, evaluation anxiety, inattention, limited intelligence, etc), but scoring below the probabilities of chance alone most likely indicates deliberate deception. Scoring below the probabilities of chance is strong evidence of malingering; it provides strong evidence that the examinee received the sensory cues and denied the perception.Deceptive examinees miss the expected 50% accuracy mark for two main reasons. First, the symptom validity technique confronts deceptive examinees quite directly, for it is difficult to maintain a properly randomized response pattern that will result in a score within the range of chance in 100 trials. Second, deceptive examinees presume that the impaired performance requires less than 50% accuracy. Deceptive examinees usually do worse than chance because they intentionally suppress the correct answers when they know them.Although a compelling conclusion is that the examinee who scores below probabilities is deliberately motivated to perform poorly, malingering must be concluded from the total clinical context.2
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Leon H. Ensalada (1999) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: