Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ancestral herpesviruses were alive and well when dinosaurs ruled the planet.1 These ancient herpesviruses obviously were more successful than dinosaurs at adaptation during the Jurassic and Cretaceous periods (200 million to 70 million years before the present). Molecular phylogenetic analyses suggest that the progenitor varicella-zoster virus (VZV) arose some 70 million years ago, probably in small mammals during the Paleocene Epoch1,2 (Fig 1). VZV has subsequently co-evolved with early humankind, developing its biphasic mode of survival as chickenpox (primary infection) and shingles (reactivation). In prehistoric times, shingles was the most likely means by which the virus was maintained within small populations of humans. In other words, an elder would develop shingles and thereby transmit virus to the children who had not previously contracted chickenpox. Thus, the properties of VZV latency and reactivation have served the virus well as it co-evolved with humankind during the great migrations out of Africa into Asia and later into Europe. As populations increased and urban centers developed, VZV was more commonly transmitted as chickenpox directly from child to child residing in relative proximity, especially within elementary schools in contemporary society.VZV has the smallest genome of the human herpesviruses, with approximately 69 open reading frames (ORFs)3 (Fig 2). In general, the VZV genome is considered to be very stable and a logical conclusion is that VZV is the same virus worldwide, regardless of whether it is isolated in North America, Asia, or Europe. Based on the likely pathogenesis of chickenpox, VZV may undergo only 20 replication cycles in the lifetime of a healthy individual and therefore few opportunities exist for mutations to occur.4 The one exception is prolonged therapy of persistent VZV infection in severely immunocompromised patients (eg, acquired immunodeficiency syndrome), which has led to acyclovir-resistant mutant viruses on rare occasions.5,6Otherwise, only minor differences have been detected by DNA restriction analyses and polymerase chain reaction amplifications between VZV strains from the United States, Europe, and Japan, and these genetic polymorphisms have not been correlated with altered VZV antigenicity or new serotypes.7,8 This stability of the VZV DNA genome stands in marked contrast to the relative instability of the genomes of many RNA viruses, eg, influenza A; with the last mentioned virus, immunologic pressure leads to the selection of mutations on an annual basis.9Surprisingly, a community VZV isolate has now been identified that has lost a monoclonal antibody binding site (epitope) on the major VZV surface protein called gE (ORF 68).10 In previous studies conducted during the last 15 years, this same monoclonal antibody has identified enumerable VZV isolates collected by the author in Texas and Iowa. The monoclonal antibody also bound to cells infected with the Japanese Oka varicella vaccine virus, as well as VZV isolates acquired from children in England. When the gE gene from the mutant strain was sequenced, the results showed that there was a substitution in one on the 12 amino acids that comprise the epitope defined by the same monoclonal antibody. This alteration in a major VZV surface protein, which is sometimes called antigenic drift, has not been known to occur in a virus presumed to be very stable genetically. Earlier, another laboratory reported that several Japanese strains lack an antibody binding site on the ORF 10 protein.11 Unlike VZV gE, the ORF 10 product is not located on the surface of the virus; rather, the ORF 10 product is part of the internal tegument (Fig 2). Because the ORF 10 protein is hidden within the virion, its mutation is less likely to be caused by immunologic pressure. Instead, the ORF 10 variation may represent an interesting example of the founder effect, whereby a mutation arises and is perpetuated in one geographic area (in this case, Japan).12The fact that there are now two documented genetic alterations in VZV epitopes indicates that VZV is less immutable than previously thought. What are the implications of these findings? Succinctly put, the above reports show that not all VZV isolates from around the world are exactly the same in their immunologic properties. Nevertheless, VZV is a complex virus with numerous other antigenic determinants. Until the recent recognition that VZV could lose an epitope, there was little reason to further evaluate the different antigenic sites on the virion. Certainly, the worldwide clinical studies of varicella vaccine which began in Japan in the 1970s and continued in the United States and Europe in the 1980s and early 1990s firmly established that most antigenic sites on the virion are shared by geographically diverse VZV strains everywhere. For this reason, the varicella vaccination programs have demonstrated efficacy in the prevention of community acquired chickenpox in Japan and the United States.13–15In summary, this commentary presents support for the proposition raised by McGeoch, Davison and colleagues1,3 that herpesviruses including VZV have cospeciated with humans and will continue to co-evolve; they speculated that further mutations are to be expected in contemporary times and, indeed, these mutations have now occurred. The next question: will more mutations be found? The answer seems to be in the affirmative, but the mutation rate is likely to be extremely slow. Therefore, this commentary further reinforces the emphasis on universal varicella vaccination of young children. If all children were immunized in the near future, there would be markedly less occasion for a mutant VZV strain to emerge as a medically relevant problem.Even after 70 million years, VZV remains an elusive quarry.The research was supported by National Institutes of Health Grants AI22795 and AI36884.I thank the VZV researchers listed in the references for helpful conversations about their related cited work.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Charles Grose (1999) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: