Key result
Duplex ultrasound can safely replace invasive contrast arteriography for planning carotid endarterectomy in most patients, avoiding the risks and costs of the invasive procedure.
Why the study?
Does Duplex ultrasound allow for safe preoperative planning of vascular surgery compared to contrast arteriography in patients with arterial disease?
Does Duplex ultrasound allow for safe preoperative planning of vascular surgery compared to contrast arteriography in patients with arterial disease?
Duplex ultrasound is a viable noninvasive alternative to contrast arteriography for preoperative planning in many patients undergoing vascular surgery, particularly carotid endarterectomy.
May support duplex ultrasound for carotid endarterectomy planning; leaves open need for randomized confirmation before routine adoption.
Although contrast arteriography has served as the historical 'gold standard' for diagnosis of arterial disease, recent improvements in noninvasive diagnostic methods have made it possible to plan surgical treatment without subjecting patients to this invasive procedure. This approach avoids both the risks and costs associated with arteriography. Duplex scanning has become the standard noninvasive test for extracranial carotid artery disease, and it can also be used to directly evaluate the lower extremity arteries. In addition to the standard duplex criteria for classification of carotid stenosis, new criteria are available that reflect the stenosis thresholds identified in randomized clinical trials. Clinical experience has clearly shown that carotid endarterectomy can be performed safely based on the duplex scan alone in the majority of patients: however, arteriography is still indicated in selected cases. The evaluation of lower extremity arterial disease requires examination of multiple arterial segments, and most vascular surgeons still rely on the anatomic detail provided by arteriography for preoperative planning. Still, it may be possible to avoid formal preoperative arteriography in selected patients by using a combination of lower extremity duplex scanning and intraoperative arteriography. Further developments in noninvasive testing will continue to reduce the need for diagnostic arteriography prior to direct arterial surgery.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
R. Eugene Zierler (1999) conducted a review in Arterial disease. Duplex ultrasound vs. Contrast arteriography was evaluated. Duplex ultrasound can safely replace invasive contrast arteriography for planning carotid endarterectomy in most patients, avoiding the risks and costs of the invasive procedure.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: