Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In the preface1 to this supplement, we pointed out that pediatricians and other clinicians have made major contributions to the discovery of environmental toxicants. Many acute illnesses that are caused by high exposures to some toxicants are clinically diagnosable or at least are commonly in the differential diagnosis, eg, organophosphate poisoning, infant botulism, acute lead encephalopathy, carbon monoxide poisoning, acrodynia, hypervitaminosis A and some cases of aplastic anemia, convulsions, asthma, respiratory distress, methemoglobinemia, Reyes syndrome, kernicterus, and many of the recognizable syndromes that result from exposures to teratogenic drugs and chemicals. In contrast to the obvious effects of high exposures to environmental toxicants, there is less information and less certainty concerning the magnitude of the contribution of many low exposures of environmental toxicants to morbidity, mortality, and subtle alterations in children as well as adults or how the effects of these exposures vary with age or chronicity of exposure.We also informed the readership that we were going to address the issue of environmental toxicology from both a clinical and a toxicologic viewpoint. Very low exposures to environmental toxicants may lead to diseases that resemble many common illnesses that have other causes, or they may lead to decrements in functioning that are subtle or nonspecific. It is an almost insurmountable task for individual practitioners to conclude a cause-and-effect relationship from low exposures to environmental toxicants among patients in the physician’s patient population. Only well-planned, sophisticated epidemiologic and animal studies can answer the questions that pertain to the toxicity of low-level exposures to environmental toxicants, given that not all individuals will be affected equally, if at all, at any particular level of exposure.Many of the previous multi-authored compendia that have been published by groups of scientists have been unified in their conclusions that environmental toxicants are a very serious problem and that children are uniformly more vulnerable to these toxicants. Other publications have taken the opposite viewpoint, namely, that environmental toxicants are not a major problem and that children are not uniformly more sensitive or vulnerable. In the present publication, there are 30 articles, many with multiple authors. These authors were selected because they have an interest in this subject and have expertise in this subject, not because they have expressed a particular viewpoint. In fact, there is disagreement about many of the issues discussed in this supplement. There is no uniformity of opinion regarding the magnitude of impact that environmental toxicants have on the health of adults and children. This is attributable to many reasons, including a lack of definitive information on population exposure, no-adverse-effect level (NOAEL), toxicokinetics, toxicodynamics, and mechanism of action (MOA) of many environmental toxicants, despite the profound importance of such information to the health and future functioning of our nation’s children.During the past year and one half since we initiated the preparation of this supplement to Pediatrics, we collected >300 new publications that deal with environmental medicine and specific environmental toxicants, including 2 books and another supplement to Pediatrics that deals with the subject of environmental health in children.2–4 We cannot review all of the articles; however, we can comment on a number that will demonstrate that the uncertainty about risks and the need for additional high-quality research has not changed in the past year and one half.The book edited by Juberg,2 entitled Are Children More Vulnerable to Environmental Chemicals? Scientific and Regulatory Issues in Perspective, was published by the American Council on Science and Health, an organization that is supported by donations from industry, private citizens, and grants. The American Council on Science and Health is interested in proper nutrition and the risks of chemicals in the environment, alcohol, smoking, and many other environmental issues. The question asked by the authors in this book is, “Are children uniquely susceptible and at an increased risk of suffering health effects from various exposures, particularly those involving environmental chemicals?” The answer to this question provided by the authors is, “It depends.” The authors’ conclusion is that toxicology, exposure analysis, environmental health, pediatrics, and risk analysis teach us that “children may be more, less, or equally susceptible to environmental hazards” in comparison with adults. The authors also noted, “We have learned, through experience, of several examples where children are uniquely susceptible to specific hazards, and we have taken action to reduce child exposure. It is the position of the authors that the majority of chemicals in our environment that are detected at very low levels are probably not a risk for either children or adults.” Dr C. Everett Koop wrote the preface to this book,2 stating, “If indeed children are at risk and are particularly vulnerable to trace levels of environmental chemicals, then we should promote highly restrictive regulatory policies even if they are costly. If, however the science leads us to the conclusion that children are not more vulnerable than adults, then the justification for such expenditures evaporates.”Inherent in Dr Koop’s conclusion is that we need accurate scientific studies to determine whether there is a cause-and-effect relationship between trace amounts of chemicals and deleterious effects. We agree with that concept. The important question is whether trace amounts of specific chemicals provide exposures that are above the NOAEL for children and whether the NOAEL is different for children than it is for adults. Each potential toxicant has to be studied to determine its NOAEL; this is essential both for prudent public policy and for the health of children.The second book was written by Donald T. Wigle and is titled Child Health and the Environment.3 Dr Wigle is an epidemiologist and physician and an affiliate scientist at the Institute of Population Health in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. The book is a single-authored text with an extensive bibliography. He performed a risk analysis for a very large number of environmental toxicants. In the preface, Dr Wigle states, “Children differ profoundly from adults with respect to physiology, metabolism, growth, development, and behavior. By interfering with child growth and development during critical time periods, environmental hazards may cause structural and functional deficits and lifelong disability.”This is an important statement and could be misinterpreted to indicate that the main issue is that children are universally more vulnerable to all environmental toxicants at lower exposures than are adults. Dr Wigle explained that even if children and adults had the same NOAEL for toxicity for a particular toxicant, the effect on the embryo, child, and adolescent could be more serious because a developing organism is still in the formative stages of development.In many places in the text, Wigle discusses the “Precautionary Principle.” He says, “Modern use of the precautionary principle in environmental health can be traced to the 1992 United Nations Conference on Environment and Development that promulgated the Rio Declaration. Under the precautionary principle, lack of full scientific certainty does not justify postponement of cost-effective measures to prevent significant potential public health risks. This book documents several historic examples of environment-related child health disasters resulting from failure to apply the precautionary principle.”The precautionary principle is a profoundly important concept that is not always operationalized to all parties’ satisfaction. One example that Wigle used to illustrate where the precautionary principle should have been invoked is lead poisoning, and we agree. Even today, primary prevention of this ubiquitous toxin still remains inadequate despite mounting evidence of debilitating effects at very low levels. The opposite extreme, however, occurs when actions are taken in the name of the precautionary principle that are not based on scientific information. Politics, public pressure, inadvertent misinterpretation of the data, and fear of birth defects and cancer all are reasons for unfortunate actions that are based on the fear of environmental toxicants. The banning of Alar and cyclamates, the destruction of the New Jersey cranberry crop, the box warning for progestin-containing drugs for birth defects initiated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 1977, and many other actions demonstrate that invoking the precautionary principle is a very complicated issue that can be beneficial or detrimental to public health and the economic best interests of the nation.Wigle says, “Children’s environmental health is increasingly recognized as a global health issue of great importance.” With respect to lead poisoning, bacterially contaminated water supplies, injuries, environmental tobacco smoke, sunburns, and the need to monitor and study the effects of children’s exposure to many other potential toxicants and then act to protect children as the data suggests, he is correct, but if he is including low-population exposures from mercury, arsenic, manganese, cadmium, polychlorinated biphenyls, dioxin, phthalates, acrylamide, pesticides, endocrine disrupters, bisphenol, low-frequency electromagnetic fields, microwave electromagnetic field frequencies, and nuclear power plants, then his concerns are not justified by our current state of knowledge, as we do not have sufficient evidence of negative effects at levels commonly experienced. The important message in and from this book, as is true of this supplement, is that we need more epidemiologic, toxicologic, teratologic, and MOA research if proper assessment of the risk of these environmental toxicants is to be determined.The third publication is a supplement to Pediatrics published in July 2003 titled “A Partnership to Establish an Environmental Safety Net for Children.”4 This monograph contains a number of articles selected from a workshop that was held in March 2001. The purpose of the workshop and publication was to educate pediatricians about how to diagnose and treat environmentally caused diseases. The workshop occurred 3 years ago, and it would be very useful to have a progress report on whether their goal of training pediatricians to be able to diagnose and treat environmentally caused diseases has been achieved.There is an excellent article in this monograph by Linet from the of the In the cause of some there are no environmental toxicants The authors studies of have a large number of risk is about the cause of particularly the of these and to in no more than to of different of environmental exposures and to of the of cancer second and and the from these and other has some new the cause of remains article entitled “Are in the 2003 issue of The article that the and the scientific evidence does not that any health are with the use of the and the used 2 extensive and studies published by the and the Institute of of the of the of the the article in that that when were to in studies for one The to this in study the with the that may be a One cannot determine risks from when the and animal studies do not indicate that there is an increased risks are from in epidemiologic studies and to a from the and animal studies are then the studies may in the MOA but not the A publication such as may be for of environmental risks from in however, there have been other in the scientific that to that in studies can be used for the risks of environmental The scientists in to determine risks from in studies in that should be on and in animal the past 2 many in animal studies that used have been particular studies demonstrate the and of animal as well as the in from animal studies to The publication is by entitled Vulnerable for of for The authors studied an organophosphate that has had its use in the United because of concerns about the These MOA studies for effect on One or 2 of were on to or to levels were of the a significant in that for of the exposure the studied the effects of in an in animal the are of use in the risks of for the this was an study with to the problem of risk us a study that would be to be a in animal toxicology study published by entitled of A in This is, almost a study for the There was and some in at the a risk analysis for in the need 2 more of information that are not present in the but this information is present in other studied and in the second The were able to exposure data in the and the The of was with a of to It that these levels are the exposure in the but cannot be because we do not have the same data in the that in the we do not the of in the at the exposure. we do not whether the and effects of are in the and the can how risk analysis can be if the to the risk analysis and conclusion on the accurate and of studies of and may to be a in the field of risk it is more in several places in this supplement, a of that and We that in the past one and one half this supplement was articles concerning environmental toxicants have been There have been no in risk analysis or definitive conclusions about any particular there still the same and about the effects of toxicants and the by those have that the risks have been and those have that environmental chemicals are a major cause of and still A review of the articles published in and 2003 with the effects of environmental exposure to pesticides, the state of our knowledge, the and the questions that have to be of these articles are and some are but all of the articles are a or any other these articles, then how would the information in whether environmental exposures to a risk to their the excellent article by in this supplement that the of the of and the very of all used that are used in and the of exposures to with a in birth and and for exposures to a in birth and in a low population of American and The that study evidence that environmental at levels in New There were and In these 3 the birth was and the birth was and and the was and The levels of in these 3 of patients were and The levels of in the 3 of patients were and With these very low levels of and should one conclude that the have a relationship to the in The authors pointed out that of at can reduce the number of and result in effects in this publication would not be with the in birth and birth in this of patients and would not that the in in these children that there was a in or a risk of in the children with the in the to the and the was at and was at on to of there was a in to by of A of were as adults with large of and and the had the in These the number of and the that exposure to in the to increased to the effects of exposure in the The authors that their a potential there are some with this study if one is interested in the data for risk These no to a risk assessment for in the it does provide with a to study with some in the and to a of and that was in the The of exposure was very The exposure for and was and The exposure for and was and There is a from the to the exposure, there was no effect on or There was a in but it occurred in the very exposure. could an exposure of of the reduce the when the exposure had no performed a study of had exposures to chemicals, and These had children with and and The authors that exposures not to the of these in the population. There were no in this and a of the were to to and The exposure during occurred on to or to The had and when exposure occurred Administration of to the developing or was less to the than exposure during the of at to have no effects. The that the had lower than the to This is an namely, that the is less susceptible to a toxicant than the It is to apply these to the because the exposures that were used were very high and were many of the the was The exposure that in some effects is many the environmental an of of the great with exposures to and a of not an such as is also with large conclude a with this of for a one would that an animal would be able to be the risk of cancer in to exposure to of among children a of and children a of were selected by The was with to all of risk were it that exposure to an important in the of studied with children and the of birth the of and the of the children. The children in the previous study by these The of the of birth defects from the The of birth defects was is the by the for and as the for the The that the of birth defects in those in the at the time of was as great This study is not because the in birth defects would have to be in the was were with cancer drugs and the of the in not have an in with birth it is very that pesticides, do not have potential to cancer drugs or could the of studied the in to the toxicity of and The published concerning acute of with that have a lower than This was also true for the The question by the was whether this increased in the at low exposures that would be present in the environment and The question was to determine whether regulatory to protect the public from environmental exposure had to the increased of the that was at the studies involving to the and at various in were was in and A study was performed in that were to the and The that at a number of low environmental exposures to the of was in than in the and the were less sensitive than the adults. There was no in the to the in the as with the These studies any that the is more sensitive and more vulnerable to environmental are about the impact of environmental toxicants on the developing The is and there is significant to the effects of The authors are about the lack of of sensitive to study the of the developing and reduce uncertainty about the of effects exposure to environmental and the of among of with use This is a study in exposure is by and use in 2 One used a of the at a level that economic and the other of The was that the exposures were lower in the A was to and The were the of and birth and exposures exposures in and during had to have been The were as is not an epidemiologic in the exposure has not been The a large number of chemicals, and there is no to determine whether any of the study population had a significant exposure, the NOAEL for any of the used by the of the the of these The data are also not In the the birth is 3 than in the the authors that should pesticides, they the population to with the because the effects are In cannot any should be pointed out as that is a very of the that are used in the United the of in this and use of for of and published in of the concept that children are provided a analysis of the and between children and adults as of a of the Environmental These authors the in an determine if there are between children and adults that may be to risk assessment of of The authors provided data that are about the between children and adults, but they also pointed out the need for studies that are to risk with that are they that by of age and in many even are almost by year of In many cases children are less sensitive than adults.” that it is true that are more sensitive to high exposures of some environmental toxicants, the that this is not a that can be to low-level environmental exposures to these same could the many other articles that deal with but the would not these publications the to conclude that there is or is not a significant risk from environmental exposure to is this publications in the past 2 to 3 years evidence that even if we are to determine the magnitude of the impact of environmental chemicals on in children and adults, many scientists have taken a reduce our exposure to The research of is to in that and in and other and that the impact of these toxicants are probably more important than environmental chemicals that have been the It is a and the concept has some scientific that that are the level of these toxicants. with that prevent or protect the population from eg, other Environmental and the for and to a of chemicals of that are at on the of The has chemicals. The is based on the of at the and the potential for exposure. We that pediatricians or other clinicians would not on this for information on whether a is a to his or A very important of information is in this the or exposure that is A of the population exposure and the NOAEL is even to clinicians and scientists are not with the science of more patients are affected by water in the United year than by of the chemicals on this the of In his he pointed out that of toxicants, and are provide the risk at various exposures for the with the NOAEL; and the of the population and their that those authors are to the because it that their the importance of the risks of environmental chemicals. The authors are from and the of Health, and these are serious to This the of in many of In the of the risks of environmental exposures, have to be made with to the of environmental risks. or or prevent Other would but we cannot even to the if we do not have data on the risks of low-level exposures to environmental toxicants. an a publication that lead exposures in the to are with a in additional that the effect is in and the is in the lower then how should we whether we have to lead even to primary or the present level as cannot that has been in this supplement. we will the concerning the of in children and their A number of publications have the of these is about whether the of to as is are not and the that the these can have an impact on the child and the We some of the of this of but there are on the diagnosis, is not an task in on the diagnosis, it is to how the of this of diseases could a of It is to studies that deal with environmental toxicants and because there is about the diagnosis, but the of diseases or very to to determine their concerns about environmental chemicals and and their differential effect on the and child are justified in we do not have information not to be One cannot the impact of environmental toxicants information of the population exposure and the This can be from animal toxicology studies and excellent epidemiologic studies with and information in the and animal it is essential that we the that can be from the articles in this supplement are as We have this supplement to pediatricians in the that the articles will their interest in the that deals with environmental A of toxicology will to their patients about the risk or lack of risks of environmental will also that a scientists have taken that environmental toxicants are a major health and some have the risks of exposures on the health of children. individual chemicals, we have examples of serious effects and no but for chemicals, we do not have is the of this supplement is the for more and toxicology
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brent et al. (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: