Key result
ESP-block and QL-block provided a similar quality of recovery after anesthesia for abdominal hysterectomies, with median QoR-15 scores of 124 and 129, respectively.
Why the study?
Comparative studies of different fascial plane blocks in abdominal hysterectomies are lacking, and recovery quality after such surgery is rarely established.
Does anterior QL-block compared to ESP-block improve quality of recovery in patients undergoing abdominal hysterectomy with general anesthesia?
Cohort (n=48)
Randomized (via random.org)
No
Does anterior QL-block compared to ESP-block improve quality of recovery in patients undergoing abdominal hysterectomy with general anesthesia?
Both ESP-block and QL-block provide satisfactory to good quality of recovery after abdominal hysterectomy with no significant difference between the two techniques.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Comparable QoR-15 scores with ESP and QL blocks indicate similar recovery; leaves open need for RCTs to guide block selection.
Background. Studies show conflicting results for different types of anesthesia in abdominal hysterectomies. There is a lack of published comparative studies where included data about different types of fascial plane blocks in abdominal hysterectomies, and the quality of recovery after such type of surgery is established rarely. The aim of the study was to assess the level of recovery quality (using QoR-15 -quality of recovery questionnaire) after anesthesia for abdominal hysterectomies with the QL-block and the ESP-block in addition to general anesthesia. Materials and methods. 48 patients who required abdominal hysterectomy were included. All patients were divided into two groups. In both groups general anesthesia was used. In addition, the ESP-block was performed preoperatively in group I, and the anterior QL-block was performed in group II. Stages: preoperative period (pre), intraoperative period (h0 ) and 6 hours (h6 ), 12 hours (h12), 24 hours (h24), 48 hours (h48), 72 hours (h72) after surgery. We checked the quality of recovery after anesthesia with QoR-15, level of pain according to the VAS, intraoperative need for fentanyl (μg/hour), daily need for morphine (mg/day), dexketoprofen and paracetamol prescribing were examined. Results and discussion. It was found that the quality of recovery after anesthesia was 124 [92; 131] points in the 1st group and 129 [90; 132] points in 2nd group (p>0,05). The level of pain according to the VAS in group I at h6 and h12 was 5.5 [4.0; 9.0] and 4.5 [3.5; 7.5] points, while in group II – 5.7 [4.1; 9.0] and 4.6 [3.6; 7.3] points, respectively (p>0.05). In the h0 stage of the study, the dosage of fentanyl in group II was 500 [300; 700] μg/h, while in group I it was 400 [300; 700] μg/h (p>0.05). The need for morphine at the h24 stage was the same – 5.0 [5.0; 10.0] mg/day in group I and 5.0 [5.0; 10.0] mg/day in group II. At the h48 stage there was a tendency for higher doses of dexketoprofen in the group I – 100 [75; 150] mg/day, while in group II – 75 [50; 150] mg/day (p>0.05). Conclusion. It was established that the quality of recovery after anesthesia using ESP-block and QL-block was from the «satisfactory» to the «good» level with no statistical differences within the groups.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A. V. Ryzhkovskyi (2024) conducted a cohort in Abdominal hysterectomy (n=48). Erector Spinae Plane (ESP) block vs. Anterior Quadratus Lumborum (QL) block was evaluated on Quality of recovery after anesthesia according to the QoR-15 questionnaire (p=>0.05). ESP-block and QL-block provided a similar quality of recovery after anesthesia for abdominal hysterectomies, with median QoR-15 scores of 124 and 129, respectively.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: