Key result
A flattened hierarchy demonstrated superior performance by junior anaesthetists in challenging deliberately incompetent seniors compared with a steep hierarchy group in a simulated scenario.
Why the study?
Does a flattened hierarchy environment improve the performance of junior anaesthetists in challenging incompetent seniors?
Does a flattened hierarchy environment improve the performance of junior anaesthetists in challenging incompetent seniors?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Flattened medical hierarchies may empower junior staff to challenge unsafe practices and improve patient safety.
Friedman et al.'s paper and Palanisamy and Jenkins’ accompanying editorial re-inforce the detrimental effects of steep hierarchy gradients on patient safety 1, 2. Elements of the Elaine Bromiley case further underlined the importance of human factors in mainstream UK anaesthetic practice 3. We were surprised by the pessimistic tone of Friedman et al.'s results. In what we consider to be a well-conducted (albeit probably underpowered) study, the flattened hierarchy group demonstrated superior performance by junior anaesthetists in challenging deliberately incompetent seniors (in a simulated scenario), compared with a steep hierarchy group. Indeed, the sole occasion a junior achieved the maximum intervention rating (physically preventing their senior from further harming the simulated patient) occurred in the flat hierarchy group. Study participants were given four opportunities to intervene, with their single most assertive intervention being recorded as a score between 1–6, with non-integer mean scores possible. Did the authors consider using cumulative scores (i.e. from 4–24), which might have allowed for greater discrimination between groups, given the small sample size? Despite this methodological concern, the findings of this study chime with routine practice, where we consider it a duty of senior anaesthetists to create an inclusive environment for the anaesthetic team, thereby promoting patient safety. The paper refers to discussion by Malcolm Gladwell in his book ‘Outliers’ about cultural differences to hierarchy 4, which in turn has a basis in Hofstede's dimensions, specifically the power-distance index (PDI) 5. Friedman et al. speculate that ‘traditional’ medical training overwhelms people who would otherwise be comfortable challenging authority figures 1, based on finding similarly inhibited behaviours to authority amongst resident doctors in Japan (PDI 54 – steeper hierarchy) compared to the US (PDI 40 – flatter hierarchy) 6. The UK PDI is lower still (35 (Ireland 28)), yet inhibitory consultant behaviour continues to create reticent juniors in routine UK practice. All anaesthetists have worked within both steep and flat hierarchies, and yet we suggest that most anaesthetists would prefer to work in - and receive care from - hospitals that encourage the latter. It is essential that the lessons learnt from failures in the Elaine Bromiley case continue to drive human factors research and patient safety improvement.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
McMaster et al. (2015) conducted a letter in Medical hierarchy and patient safety. Flattened hierarchy vs. Steep hierarchy was evaluated on Performance by junior anaesthetists in challenging deliberately incompetent seniors in a simulated scenario. A flattened hierarchy demonstrated superior performance by junior anaesthetists in challenging deliberately incompetent seniors compared with a steep hierarchy group in a simulated scenario.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: