Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper investigates the form of male street socialization known asbirzhaas an informal practice which upholds norms opposed to those emanating from official institutions. Repressed by state power,birzhafalls into the conceptual framework which regards informal practices as forms of resistance generating counterhegemonic narratives vis-à-vis the official system. The paper questions this framework’s appropriateness for understanding informality, analysingbirzhaas an ambivalent practice which does not fit the notion of resistance. Drawing upon fieldwork data, literary and media sources, the relation betweenbirzhaand state power in late Soviet years, in the 1990s, and under Saakashvili’s rule (2003–2012) is analysed. The paper indicates that the relation betweenbirzhaand official power has been alternatively underpinned by toleration, mutual dependence, or repression. Yet,birzhahas a hierarchical and conservative structure which thwarts its potential as a source of social and political change. The conceptualization of informal practices as resistance is critically assessed along two lines. Firstly, the “romanticisation” of informality denies the impact that certain practices may have on wider social and political debates. Secondly, a perspective on informal practices as counterhegemonic overlooks these practices’ ambivalence between openness and selectivity, equality and hierarchy, and change and conservation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Costanza Curro (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: