Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Although most countries use animals as companions, for production and for sport and entertainment, the scale and variety of animals in Australia is unparalleled. Community attitudes to livestock animal welfare can impact on how Governments either react to publicized “animal welfare events” or regulate management practices in industry. There has been a trend for community behaviors that can impact on the livestock industries to become more prevalent over time. The livestock industries increasingly see that changing community values need to be addressed in a proactive way in order not just to maintain markets, but also to protect license to farm. Australian society is characterized by a pervasive influence of animals in all aspects of human life. Although most countries use animals as companions, for production and for sport and entertainment, the scale and variety of animals in Australia is unparalleled. For example, companion animal ownership in Australia is among the highest in the world with 62% of households owning a pet (Animal Medicines Australia, 2016). Australia was the highest exporter in the world of beef, lamb, and mutton and goat meat in 2015 (MLA, 2015). Australia also uses kangaroos for human and animal food and deals with pockets of kangaroo overpopulation. Feral dogs, cats, goats, rabbits, and other introduced species pose a threat to wildlife or farming. Although there have been animal welfare concerns expressed by the public in the conventional media and on social media about companion animals, wildlife, animals used in sport and recreation, this chapter will focus on livestock, it being the focus of this book. Although public concerns about livestock animal welfare are well documented in several countries (e.g., European Commission, 2007; Gracia, 2013), there has been an on-going interest in these concerns in Australia (e.g., Parbery and Wilkinson, 2012; Coleman et al., 2015, 2017). These concerns about the livestock industries are not the major drivers of consumer-purchasing decisions because attitudes to livestock welfare is only one of the predictors of purchasing behavior with price, healthiness, and local production being more important for consumers (Coleman et al. 2005; Coleman and Toukhsati 2006). Public attitudes to livestock farming may, however, be a threat to social license to farm (Martin and Shepheard, 2011; Coleman et al., 2015, 2017). An attempt will be made here to tease out some of the possible effects of public concerns about farm animal welfare on the livestock industries in Australia. Suggestions to facilitate discourse among the various stakeholders will be raised with a view to achieving a degree of convergence in opinions and in agreed approaches to livestock farming in the future. The relevance of public attitude to consumption of animal products and to social license to farm will now be discussed in the context of the Australian experience. Coleman and Toukhsati (2006) surveyed 516 Australian respondents about their perceptions toward farm animal welfare and meat purchases. Of these 516 respondents, 116 respondents were interviewed at point-of-sale. Attitudes, in combination with demographic variables, predicted 13.3% of the variance in self-reported sheep meat purchases but did not significantly predict point-of-sale sheep meat purchases. The results also indicated that, although welfare was moderately important, factors other than concern for animal welfare were more predictive of pork, beef, and sheep meat purchases. The fact that animal welfare attitudes play only a moderate role in predicting some consumer behaviors is perhaps not surprising considering that a host of other factors influence purchasing behaviors. Past research has shown that when food attributes relevant to meat purchasing are ranked in order of importance, freshness, taste, flavor, safety, and price are rated as extremely important, and attributes such as humane treatment and environmentally friendly are rated as very important (Curtis et al., 2011). Australian consumers rank animal welfare fifth in a list of 15 attributes (Coleman and Toukhsati, 2006) and is only weakly correlated with beef and uncorrelated with lamb purchases. Many consumers do report thinking about animal welfare when they purchase meat and meat products in Australia (Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs, 2011) and elsewhere (European Commission, 2007), but it is the other factors that are most influential in purchasing decisions. However, that is not to say that animal welfare concerns are of limited relevance to the livestock industries, but its role is complex. Red meat consumption per capita is declining in Australia but pork and chicken consumption has been rising (Ratnasiri and Bandara, 2017) despite the fact that the latter attract the greatest public concerns about animal welfare (Coleman et al., 2014). There is relatively little research that specifically targets consumer attitudes to sheep welfare affecting the purchase of wool products. In three southern U.S. states, consumers were willing to pay more for U.S. wool over Australian wool (Hustvedt et al., 2013). However, this research targeted ethnocentricity without reference to environmental or welfare concerns so it is not known what aspects of the Australian product were less preferred. The practice of mulesing (discussed in more detail below) has attracted considerable adverse publicity. There was considerable media reporting of calls by People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) to boycott the purchase of Australian wool and instances where buyers did boycott the purchase of Australian wool (for example, Brennan, 2009). This boycotting was done by wool buyers, not consumers. In fact, this is a similar pattern to that observed with meat products. It is often somewhere in the supply chain that constraints on the purchasing of sheep products, not at the consumer level. Despite these boycotts, the Australian national flock numbers are higher in 2016 than they were in 2009. Also, in the 2 years, October 2014 to October 2016, wool prices have steadily risen (Australian Wool Innovation, 2016). Nevertheless, Lee (2014) used the Theory of Planned Behavior (Ajzen, 1991) approach to investigate the effects of one- and two-sided communications for and against the purchasing of fashion goods based on animal products including wool (Lee, 2014). He found that attitudes and normative beliefs predicted intention to purchase wool products. Importantly, one-sided messages that described mulesing made respondents’ attitudes more negative, whereas positive messages about the superiority of wool as a fiber did not make attitudes more positive. Respondents exposed to both messages had more negative attitudes than those exposed to irrelevant or positive information, but slightly more positive than those exposed just to negative information. This indicates that for the general community to be properly informed both positive and negative information need to be addressed. The sheep industry needs to discuss sheep welfare issues transparently if it wishes to maintain trust and counter the adverse publicity that adverse media campaigns produce. These behaviors and the public opinions driving them can have a considerable influence on how Governments either react to publicized “animal welfare events” or regulate contentious management practices in industry. This is especially the case when concerns are expressed by nongovernmental animal welfare or rights organizations. The campaign by PETA in 2004 against the practice of mulesing in the Australian sheep industry is an example of this, where PETA demanded that the practice of mulesing in Australian sheep flocks cease. The industry response to this is discussed below, but the campaign received widespread media coverage and led to some countries banning the import of Australian wool. There is accumulating evidence that public attitudes to animal welfare in Australia may be relevant to community behaviors that potentially impact the livestock industries than they are to purchasing and consumption behaviors. According to Coleman and Toukhsati (2006, p.21) “community behaviours that do not require public expression or public identification” are common in relation to livestock issues and “involve taking advantage of situational opportunities to express an attitude through action”. Such behaviors (e.g., signing petitions, donating money, speaking to colleagues about animal welfare issues) and their associated public opinions can influence on how Governments either react to publicized “animal welfare events” or regulate contentious management practices in industry. Concerns about animal welfare together with concerns about issues relating to climate change, water scarcity, and declining biodiversity may all threaten farmer’s social license to farm. Social license to farm is defined by Martin and Shepheard (2011) as “…the latitude that society allows to its citizens to exploit resources for their private purposes” (2011, p. 4). Social license is granted when industries behave in a manner that is consistent, not just with their legal obligations but also with community expectations (Gunningham et al., 2004; Williams et al., 2007). Failure to fulfill the obligations inherent to social license can lead to increased litigation, increased regulations, and increasing consumer demands all of which hamper the success of industries. This is especially the case when concerns are expressed by nongovernmental animal welfare or rights organizations. The “Save Babe” campaign an example where community pressure, exerted by an animal rights organization, triggered industry changes. In 2006, Animals Australia, a federation of animal welfare groups in Australia, launched the “Save Babe” campaign to raise public awareness about the containment of sows in farrowing crates (Animals Australia, 2016). This campaign and the community pressure that followed, led directly to the pork industry making a proactive response whereby the revised Australian Code of Practice for pigs has included changes to the duration that gestating sows can be housed in stalls. Not only this but the pork industry voluntarily decided to phase out sow stalls entirely by 2017. Further to this, Coles, a major chain of supermarkets in Australia, subsequently announced that Coles Brand fresh pork products will come from sow stall-free farms. This practice was subsequently extended to all pork products including bacon and ham (Coles, 2016). The examples just cited have several consequences. On the one hand, producers are faced with the need to expend capital on changing their facilities and this impacts farm profitability or pricing of pork or both. On the other hand, public perceptions of pork production may become more favorable because of the perceived greater welfare friendliness of pork production. There has been a trend for community behaviors that can impact on the livestock industries to become more prevalent over time. Table 1 shows the changes in the frequencies with which respondents reported being engaged in community behaviors in opposition to the livestock industries between 2005 and 2014 (Coleman et al., 2017a). Most respondents engaged in at least one community behavior. Percentages of community behaviors in opposition to the livestock industries.* *Adapted from Coleman et al. (2017a). Percentages of community behaviors in opposition to the livestock industries.* *Adapted from Coleman et al. (2017a). These data show that, in Australia, the community does engage in activities that may impact the livestock industries. The most prevalent behaviors (signing petitions, donating to welfare organizations, and speaking to family and friends) are those that are relatively easy to carry out and may have less impact than lobbying politicians or calling talkback radio but they do indicate a surprisingly high level of community engagement. Coleman et al. (2016) found that information seeking and trust in information, attitudes related to animal welfare and the livestock industries, and membership of an animal welfare group, accounted for 43% of the variance in community behaviors that express dissatisfaction with the livestock industries. This study found that about 15% of 479 respondents identified themselves as opinion leaders, that is, people who tended be used as a source of animal welfare-related information by friends and neighbors, tended to be asked about livestock animal welfare and tended to tell people about livestock welfare. In general, these people held more negative views of the livestock industries, and were characterized, in particular, by more negative beliefs about livestock animal welfare, a higher self-perceived knowledge of livestock practices, but no better actual knowledge than the remainder of the population. Further, these people tended to engage in more activities in opposition to the livestock industries (Coleman, 2017b). As yet, there is no research on what, if any, role such people play in forming or reinforcing public opinions about the livestock industries. According to Martin and Shepheard (2011), working with the community, understanding their opinions toward important issues like animal welfare and the environment, in a manner indicative of cooperation rather than working against them in a defensive manner, is the most successful means to addressing threats to social license. In this light, exploring public opinions toward the livestock animal industry and the behaviors that they engage in is an important first step to engaging with the community. Coleman (2017b) has discussed public perceptions of sheep welfare in some detail, but the example of mulesing is relevant to this paper. Mulesing is the surgical procedure that removes skin from the tail and breech area of sheep in order to prevent flystrike. Flystrike, which can lead to death, is a particularly painful and stressful condition where flies lay their eggs in the soiled areas of the fleece and the maggots feed on the fleece and flesh in the area (Shutt et al., 1988; Colditz et al., 2005). Public concerns about mulesing focus not on the welfare risks of pain, stress, and mortality associated with flystrike, but on the painful and stressful surgical procedure of mulesing to prevent flystrike. As Coleman (2017b) reported, in a study that investigated the extent to which Australians approved or disapproved of mulesing, about 28% disapproved or strongly disapproved, 22% did not know and 32% neither approved nor disapproved (Coleman et al., 2014). This disapproval had increased since 2000 but has leveled out recently. In a Roy Morgan survey (Roy Morgan Research, 2000), only 3% of Australians disapproved of mulesing in 2000. By 2006, this percentage grew to 39% (Coleman and Toukhsati, 2006) but reduced to 28% in 2014 (Coleman et al., 2014). In this most recent survey, when asked to identify the correct definition of mulesing from two options presented, only 62% answered correctly. This is not much above chance. Farmers have had varying responses to this public concern. Western Australian wool producers generally held negative attitudes to the practice, but half indicated that they would continue to mules (Wells et al., 2011). Also, about half of the farmers surveyed believed that consumers don’t care about the issue. This is not too different from the survey results reported above (Coleman et al., 2014). Mulesing is still practiced. In Western Australia during 2014 to 2015, of those cases where respondents provided information (48% did not) 75% of sheep were mulesed (Lindon, 2015). The industry response to these public concerns has been to attempt to find alternatives to mulesing. There has been some progress on alternatives to mulesing (Agriculture Victoria, 2016) using intradermal technology, insecticides, targeting the sheep genome, and targeting the blowfly genome. Australian Wool Innovation that in and to the profitability of Australian has in alternatives to mulesing and with mulesing (Lindon, 2016). Although some may that the industry is in its response to public there are changes. For example, in 2016, the local was used for of mulesed sheep (Lindon, 2016). Most livestock industries are a trend to greater with production in the and chicken meat industries and an in in the other livestock industries more common in beef and sheep production and increasing in production. of Australia, research has indicated that the public is about On a was rated by the general community in as the most important of and climate issues but rated as the most important by farmers et al., However, was rated most important by the general community whereas farmers rated this as most important It is that, although the in to were similar for farmers and the general community, the for farmers was that, in farmers less to than does the general community. reported that, in the general public perceived production better animal welfare than do more Coleman et al. (2016) found that, in Australia, public of lamb as the degree on in was generally whereas in less approved and in generally respondents from and held similar This between respondents is important because it is with the often expressed view that the in public disapproval of aspects of livestock farming because of increasing to people more from farming and farming practices 2006). the attitudes of various stakeholders in the Australian sheep et al. asked the Australian general sheep sheep and to their on the of a of sheep welfare issues and possible respondents sheep welfare was but that was perceived to the most to sheep included of the sheep with blowfly environmental and related to food and and about the extent to which practices were to sheep welfare was highest for the general public on a and for producers was not raised as a high welfare although survey data indicate that the public of increasing it in public discourse for instances where the is raised in the The “Save Babe” campaign discussed is an of this, although the focus here was on the effects of of sows rather than the more general of Nevertheless, there is on-going research and of for and in response to various public concerns about production in these industries. and scale production may well become targets of similar of public concern in the future. As a with sheep and beef livestock in Australia may need to be very to for or to meat In Australia, and in the southern in can be in of sheep for as mutton in Australia may be to extended the of the two mutton in and Western Australia. There are that for example, and it to (MLA, although these have no their use is strongly in other for example in the the of Animals during 2007). Despite these an Australian study (Coleman et al., found that of the general public indicated trust in in livestock on and indicated trust in in livestock by This latter may a of adverse that had been reported in the Australian media in to sheep and by the Australian animal rights group, Animals Australia at the of the There is an campaign by animal rights groups to of sheep and It may be that are not in the but the industry is per and Australian has for the of livestock and the only that animal welfare for livestock on-going in this an to influence animal welfare in (Department of and 2017). there is a from the industry and from to continue The is a of some of the areas of public animal welfare in the Australian livestock industries. In it is similar to the in and However, there are some that are The combination of high very farming in the meat industries and the associated of livestock as well as the of farming of pigs and is to Australia. The of welfare risks to livestock that the Australian context means that there will be on-going of the industries by the general public as well as by this is to maintain a between changing community values and changes in consumption and the increasing demands for is a major by the Australian to with this was the of the Australian in provided a national where stakeholders including industry animal welfare organizations, and to animal welfare for livestock, companion animals, animals used in research and a of working some of which were and some of which were groups by the Australian groups by the Australian The an of information that is to all including the general and made progress in achieving a degree of convergence in thinking all of the some of would The Australian its of in 2014 but its are the of the Australian and can be 2017). However, as a it is no and there a need to all stakeholders with the to the major issues of the and to to that still is the Australian that is of the Research, and 2017). It is a stakeholders from the animal industries, research and the as an that to identify for animal welfare that are common to the livestock industries and to facilitate to an it some of the that were as of However, there a of a similar to that all animal species in other than food and fiber production such as companion animals, animals in research and in as well as and There is an on-going need for such a to in engage the community in addressing animal welfare issues and to the license for farmers to food and fiber in It is to how in public concern about farm animal welfare in Australia will The of public discourse in this area has shown that adverse for example, of practices in or on of public concern that by animal rights groups also have similar for example, campaigns against or against in pigs or However, the impact of these on media but this is often and has recently. Nevertheless, there is a awareness in the livestock industries of animal welfare as a high and an awareness that changing community values need to be addressed in a proactive It is that there will continue to be by the livestock industries to identify and welfare risks and the better engage the community in practices on the one and to public concerns on the This will a greater on and and less on a public It will also a from by the livestock industries to and a to public as a rather than public concerns as of a of community knowledge or Coleman is in the of and at the of and is a in the Coleman has over and one book. research focus on human including which are relevant to in the livestock industries and in the and the of and for Most has community attitudes to farm animal welfare and the impact of these attitudes on community behavior.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Grahame J. Coleman (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: