Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Continuous-wave lidar systems offer the possibility to remotely sense wind speed but are also affected by inherent differences in their measurement process compared to more traditional anemometry like cup or sonic anemometers. Their large measurement volume leads to an attenuation of turbulence. In this paper we study how different methods to derive the radial wind speed from a lidar Doppler spectrum can mitigate turbulence attenuation. The centroid, median and maximum methods are compared by estimating transfer functions and calculating root mean squared errors (RMSE) between a lidar and a sonic anemometer. Numerical simulations and experimental results both indicate that the maximum method, even though using the least amount of information from the Doppler spectrum, performs best at mitigating the volume averaging effect. However, this benefit is paid by increased signal noise due to the discretisation of the maximum method. The median method shows slight improvements over the centroid method in terms of volume averaging reduction and also resulted in the overall lowest RMSE. Thus, when the aim is to obtain point-like wind speed time series with high temporal resolution, the median method is superior to the centroid and maximum method. When comparing 10 minute averages there is no difference between the methods.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Held et al. (2018) studied this question.