Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Critical essay demonstrates that reading New Testament texts within Second Temple Judaism informs Christian theology, suggesting a necessary shift toward post-supersessionist interpretation.
This essay offers an appreciative response to Anders Runesson’s recent NTS article ‘What Does It Mean to Read New Testament Texts “within Judaism”?’ While affirming his argument that the NT writings belong historically to the body of Second Temple Jewish literature, the essay challenges Runesson’s strict separation of the historical project of reframing the NT within Judaism from theology. The essay argues that interpreting NT texts within Judaism can coincide with theological interpretation, that is, reading the NT writings as Scripture. The recent movement to understand the NT texts as Second Temple Jewish literature makes a fundamental truth-claim about the nature of the NT writings themselves – they are Jewish texts. Christians, then, canonised first-century Jewish writings as holy writ. This historical assertion necessarily exerts theological pressure on confessional readers. As theological interpreters seek to understand NT texts within their enculturated, generative contexts, they must attend to the Second Temple Jewish particularity of these writings and their theological perspectives. This should prompt the development of non- or post-supersessionist forms of theological interpretation that engage the NT writings as Second Temple literature and as Scripture.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jason F. Moraff (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: