Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, the workforce was already facing disruptive changes. The fourth industrial revolution and technology in the workplace, specifically artificial intelligence (AI), robotics, and big data, were already drastically reshaping the profile of a highly skilled worker in the 21st century. Now, the combination of challenges caused COVID-19 and these new workplace technologies are responsible for displacing entire occupations, shifting worker skills and tasks, and creating new sets of skills and tasks (World Economic Forum, 2018b). To ensure full employment of the workforce by 2030, major and possibly historic workforce transitions to new jobs, skills, and occupations will need to occur (McKinsey Global Institute, 2017). Middle skill jobs are jobs that typically require more than a high school diploma but less than a four-year degree. These jobs represent a significantly large sector of the American workforce and have been particularly vulnerable to workplace transitions (Autor, 2015; National Science Board, 2019). In an environment of workforce disruption caused by COVID-19, technology, external market forces, and globalization, middle skills workers need innovative avenues to support adaptation and development of skills for career resilience and sustainability. Analyzing news media can provide important insight into public understanding, perspectives, and support of current events and issues (Hodgetts & Chamberlain, 2014). In fact, serious analysis of American life and culture must include media (Altheide & Schneider, 2013). Immediate access to media means that evaluation of media is useful for phenomenon and emerging situations for which there is little published empirical research. Further, news media is important in helping to set a common agenda for collective action and response (Feezell, 2017). In the field of human resource development, news media analysis is a method that has not been often utilized. However, both workers and employers are exposed to news media regularly and the daily news they receive can shape their perceptions and actions in the workforce. Analysis of the public information in news reports and corporate filings can provide insight into challenges and potential focus areas for learning solutions for the middle skills workforce. While there has been much forecasting on the future transformations of labor markets, few practical approaches exist to identify reskilling and job transition opportunities, especially for middle skill workers (World Economic Forum, 2018a). This current study helps to address the gaps in literature related to general understanding of middle skill workforce learning needs while specifically examining the short- and long-term impacts of COVID-19 on middle skill education and learning and development. This article presents a thematic content analysis of media published in the United States during the first six months of the COVID-19 outbreak. The purpose of this study is to examine how the middle skill workforce has been affected by COVID-19 and specifically examine learning solutions and recommendations designed to support improved work outcomes and career sustainability of this workforce sector. This analysis of news media integrates media articles from newspapers, industry trade press, news transcripts, general news articles from newswires, company filings, stock reports, executive materials, industry analyst reports, and congressional publications from January 1, 2020 through June 25, 2020. This study will present an overview of emerging public trends in middle skill education and learning and development, suggest directions for future research, and provide implications for practice. The middle skills sector represents well paying, high demand jobs and with 17.7 million workers is a significantly large sector of the American workforce which is projected to grow to 18.5 million by 2029 (Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2020; Christo-Baker et al., 2017; National Science Board, 2019). Analysis of Bureau of Labor Statistics data of occupations requiring an associate degree, a postsecondary non-degree award, or some college (97 total) revealed that in 2019 the average annual salary was nearly $53,000 with a high of $122,000 (Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2020). This analysis also revealed stronger than average job openings with an annual average of 17,700 occupational openings projected between 2019 and 2029 and a high of 209,200 openings (Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2020). Yet, given this strong workforce demand, a skills gap exists where there is a lack of skilled workers who are qualified for available jobs. In fact, 69% of employers state that their inability to attract and retain middle skills talent limits their firm's competitiveness and ability to grow (Harvard Business School, 2016). Employers also report that human resource issues related to recruitment, training, and retention of this vital workforce are predicted to create a shortage of nearly 3.4 million skilled technical workers over the next few years (National Science Board, 2019). In today's dynamic workplace, employers are combating a skills gap which makes it difficult to recruit and retain a high technology, highly qualified, middle skill workforce. Preparation for middle skill jobs is broad and may include certificates, (academic and/or industry recognized), associate degrees, and in some cases four-year baccalaureate degrees (Land, 2012). Many institutions of higher education and industry partners are working together to make credentials stackable to provide multiple employable exit points. However, the impact of automation and technology in the workplace is beginning to change the educational requirements that students need to meet to ensure that they are learning relevant and career sustainable skills (Burning Glass Technologies, 2019). The recent COVID-19 pandemic has made this need to focus on relevant skills even more pressing for middle skill workers. While the effect of advanced technologies in the workplace is being felt across all industry sectors and jobs, middle skill and technological education growth in employment and wages are particularly vulnerable to and have declined as a result of the advances of workplace technology and automation (Autor, 2015). Additionally, there is little empirical research and few practical guidelines that focus on the importance of developing the skills needed for jobs of the future to support career sustainability, especially in the middle skill sector (McKinsey Global Institute, 2017). Developing a deeper understanding of the role that middle skill education can play provides foundational knowledge essential to supporting the nation's technical infrastructure and capacity for innovation (Frase et al., 2016). While the marketplace itself is changing based on megatrends such as globalization, robotics, AI, analytics, and many other factors, the characteristics of the individual worker are also changing. Workforce demographic trends include a large shift to a more diverse, multinational, and aging workforce (Toossi, 2016). Another major trend impacting the workforce is the emergence of “gig” or contract workers. This gig economy trend is creating seismic shifts in the workplace where the majority of new jobs created over the past 10 years were short-term, contract work (Mayln-Smith et al., 2017). These trends contribute to a growing barrier for workers without updated, relevant skills wishing to enter and remain in the world of work. These trends, already in place prior to the COVID-19 outbreak mean that work is being redesigned to accommodate new work trends and new worker values (flexibility, job enrichment, career development) and workers must be adaptable to these changes in order to sustain their careers. The COVID-19 outbreak now adds an additional layer of needed understanding of career sustaining skills to this already complex and evolving workplace dynamic. These factors are impacting careers which are lasting longer and on average spanning over 60 years (Deloitte, 2017). Success in future work environments will be dependent upon the workforce's ability to acquire new sets of skills and competencies (Mayln-Smith et al., 2017). Thus, preparing the current and future workforce with a broad spectrum of in-demand knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics will provide greater flexibility, adaptability, and agility within work. Investing in learning and development solutions can equip workers to better handle new skill requirements brought on by COVID-19 and prepare them with the 21st century skills needed to fill current and future middle skill jobs (National Institute for Certification in Engineering Technologies, n.d.). The importance of learning for the workforce is emphasized by data that suggests that every three years workers will have to relearn 35% of their jobs and every five years a worker's skill set will be half as valuable as it was previously (McGowan & Andrews, 2015; World Economic Forum, 2017). In fact, learning has been identified as the leading human capital trend most urgent to organizations (Deloitte, 2019). Eighty-six percent of chief executive officers (CEOs) rank learning and changing the way people learn as most important; yet, only 46% feel prepared to address that challenge (Deloitte, 2019). In growing middle skill industries such as manufacturing, construction, and healthcare; training for current needs is inadequate with much uncertainty about future needs (Christo-Baker et al., 2017). To be effective learning must address both current and future needs. Further, new needs spurred by the COVID-19 pandemic have demanded a clearer understanding of the role that learning plays in a high-quality workforce. The learning evolution is a major workforce trend necessitating the need for developing updated and agile curricula for technological and higher education, addressing the availability of retraining opportunities for the workforce, and enabling a mindset of lifelong learning for all (Mayln-Smith et al., 2017; World Economic Forum, 2018). A study of emerging and relevant media reports, company filings, and other reputable media sources provides an overview of public understanding of both current and future learning and development needs related to the changes prompted by the COVID-19 pandemic. The concept of sustainable careers is emerging in career and human resource development literature (Lawrence et al., 2017). The idea that individuals need to develop career competencies to support sustainability and resilience in careers has been recently spurred by current trends, external factors, changing workplace demographics, and contextual factors (technology, globalization, and the economy; Greenhuas & Kossek, 2014; McDonald & Hite, 2018; Mirsha & McDonald, 2017). Sustainable careers are “the variety of paid and unpaid work experiences that provide continual growth and renewal and that intersect multiple life contexts resulting in meaning and well-being for individuals over time” (McDonald & Hite, 2018, p. 350). The key characteristics of sustainable careers include: As the marketplace is shifting, identifying the skills and competencies needed by middle skill workers is critical to supporting their long-term career sustainability. The emergence of COVID-19 related changes has impacted many areas of predicted skills and must also be evaluated as part of preparing a highly qualified workforce with sustainable careers and skills for jobs of the future. The central aim of this media review is to identify middle skill workforce trends in learning and development related to the COVID-19 pandemic. The review is descriptive and follows an integrative synthesis approach which aims to summarize content from multiple news media sources while minimizing interpretation by the reviewer (Harden & Thomas, 2010). This analysis of news media is framed by two general questions: What is the public perception of middle skill workers and how have they been impacted by the COVID-19 outbreak? In light of COVID-19 related workforce disruptions, what stories emerge from published media to suggest needs and directions for future learning solutions targeted at improving middle skill individual and organizational outcomes? Lexis Uni (formerly LexisNexis), one of the most comprehensive news database sources (Altheide & Schneider, 2013), was used to identify 485 media articles published from January 1, 2020 through June 25, 2020 reporting the impact of COVID-19 on middle skill workers. Five primary sets of key words describing the middle skill workforce were individually searched in the advanced Lexis Uni search including: “COVID” +“middle skill” (seven articles), “COVID” +“blue collar” (247 articles), “COVID” +“skilled worker” (four articles), “COVID” + “skilled workforce” (205 articles), “COVID” + “technical workforce” (22 articles), and “COVID” + “skilled worker” (zero articles). The word “technician” was also initially used however, the articles that were returned in that search were out of the context of this paper and focused primarily on medical laboratory technicians. Also, the search initially included a search of each identified key word with the word “Corona” instead of “COVID” but that search also returned articles unrelated to COVID-19. Additional filters in the news search included articles in English and location by publication in the United States. The units of analysis included news media integrating media articles from newspapers, industry trade press, news transcripts, general news articles from newswires, company filings, stock reports, executive materials, industry analyst reports, and congressional publications. Other less reputable and less sourced publication types such as web links, blogs, web-based publications, and newsletters were excluded. After review of all 485 articles, 177 articles were included in this study. The media articles were analyzed in MaxQDA12 using thematic content analysis. Content analysis is the prominent method for studying news representations (Hodgetts, & Chamberlain, 2014). Content analysis was conducted using an adaptation of Hodgetts and Chamberlain's media content analysis process: (a) identify the topic and scope of data required; (b) identify key themes, coding, selecting, and checking for discrepancies; (c) grid, visualize, and break down data to explore emerging patterns; (d) order themes, link, and construct a new analytic story; and (e) develop an overall interpretation and writing (2014). It is important to note that in this analysis, items b and c were reversed from Hodgetts and Chamberlain's original process. The reason for this reversal is that in the original process gridding appears to be manually done however, to utilize the full data visualization capabilities of MaxQDA visual tools; code matrix and code relation browsers were used to identify connections in the data that would be difficult to identify manually. Otherwise, the other steps in the Hodgetts and Chamberlain (2014) process were followed. The findings from this study explore the strategic importance of the middle skills workforce, challenges and changes for middle skill workers and organizations as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, and middle skill learning opportunities. Table 1 provides an overview of major themes, subthemes, frequency of themes appearing in media, and types and number of articles per theme. Throughout analysis of the articles, the most frequently coded items (78 total codes in 68 articles) were those related to the strategic importance of the middle skills workforce and the need to recruit and retain this important workforce. The industries reported in the articles of this analysis include: healthcare (also biotechnology and medical devices), skilled trades, design, supply chain (logistics and transportation), information and data storage, food production, advanced textiles and materials, construction trades, welding consumables, food and agriculture, defense, aerospace, shipbuilding, advanced manufacturing, and apparel. Although unemployment has soared during the COVID-19 pandemic, the skills gap is continuing to grow. The skills gap and lack of a skilled workforce is a problem of great concern because it impedes growth for individuals, organizations, and the market as a whole. Lack of a skilled workforce was specifically mentioned in 29 articles coded 31 times as a major challenge that organizations expect to face in 2020 and beyond. This issue also impacts regional growth and community economic development. Federal and state spending has been allocated to support regional workforce development programs providing training to enhance regionally demanded skills and address the talent gap. These workforce development programs are vital to bolstering regional economies as state Representative Matt Hall of Michigan stated, “The single-largest barrier to economic growth that job providers … have communicated to me is the lack of a skilled workforce” (States News Service, 2020a). Innovations and partnerships such as Next Chapter and Generation T are also poised to support job matching and recruitment to combat the skills gap. Next Chapter company CEO said, “employers are grappling with the seemingly endemic skills gaps in healthcare, supply chain, and skilled trade fields” thus a new platform was launched to help displaced workers identify new roles with employers and sectors that are hiring (Guild Education, 2020). Instead of focusing on reemployment of existing workers, other solutions such as Generation T are focusing on recruiting new generations into the middle skill workforce. In response to the fact that one third of the skilled technical workforce will retire by 2028 and only four percent of high school seniors are considering a career in skilled trades, PeopleReady, an industrial staffing agency, is supporting the Generation T movement to reignite interest in skilled trades and reduce the future skills gap (NewsBites, 2020c). Each of these recruitment tools is targeted to prepare and recruit more qualified workers into the middle skill workforce. Across 18 different company filings and related company filing transcripts, many CEOs and business leaders acknowledged their skilled workforce as a strategic advantage. Emphasizing the importance of this workforce three elected leaders, a union president, a CEO, and the Mississippi Speaker of the House all refer to this workforce as the “backbone” of their company and the United States economy (DSV Panalpina A/S, 2020; NewsBites, 2020b, States News Service, 2020d). As organizations are scrambling to implement a variety of measures to balance the financial impact during the crisis, most express primary concern for taking care of their most critical resource, their people. Asking workers to give up net pay, furloughs, adjusting work schedules, mandatory use of vacation time, reducing number of hours, temporary layoffs, reduced use of subcontractors, restructuring, and reducing executive compensation have all been identified as strategies for rightsizing the cost base while retaining technical talent. Unfortunately, other companies have been forced to scale down the size of their workforce through more permanent layoffs. However, throughout all articles only four companies were specifically identified as utilizing layoff strategies, while 24 other documents more generally mentioned layoffs impacting middle skill workers. Regardless of the strategy selected, the importance of retaining the skilled technical workforce was a strong emphasis. A highly skilled, highly qualified middle skill workforce was identified as critical not only to managing the current crisis but also a vital part of long-term success, growth, and competitiveness. The pervasiveness of global impact on corporations and the workforce was heavily evident with 114 of the total articles referencing a global presence or global impact. Additionally, six articles identified an urgent need to shore up the middle skill workforce supporting national security in the armed forces, aerospace, supply chain, defense industry manufacturing, and telecommunications. In to the training need to prepare workers in national security and said, and training programs provide vital tools and to national security out this (NewsBites, 2020a). To address the needs of both the workforce and middle skill at and are as or for support of COVID-19 or the Workforce the and Economic and to the already Workforce and and and Other has been in the of the of National Institute of and worker providing temporary employment and training programs through state and workforce defense industry workforce and layoff a a and economic for the by a in nation's skilled and CEO of the Workforce 2020). As throughout this the strategic importance of the middle skill workforce and addressing the skills gap of this workforce the majority of the articles published about middle skills workers during this Thus, this was the and most throughout analysis of the media The variety of the types of articles addressing this topic and the pervasiveness of this across many different being emphasized from an individual worker to an organizational to a community and regional and even a national this as major public issue which collective action and response is beginning to understanding of the challenges facing the middle skill workforce provides insight into to shape learning and development programs that to and workforce needs. The challenges by this workforce most often identified by the articles in this study include general and challenges addressing analysis revealed that many middle skill workers are facing COVID-19 challenges to all working such as to working from more in the use of and in the of and However, this to be where the middle skill challenges identified in these media articles included adaptation to new business with and employers and work business have to emerge as a result of COVID-19 changes. are temporary changes requiring to new job and roles as jobs and have been to make and such as and are reporting new To these different to be all companies across a variety of and company filings, have the importance of a highly skilled, workforce with strong permanent changes to business in industries that middle skill workers are with of The importance of automation as a corporate strategy is about in over of all articles with the most automation appearing in company filings of and future a at The automation will as a result of COVID-19 It is that the current trend of automation and learning human workers will as a result of this crisis, because the of will require many companies to their declined … this environment many companies to to more workers that will jobs, barrier to and education students while jobs for those in the p. articles also mentioned new and of employers as the COVID-19 related has growth of and more types of workers, gig workers, and workers with multiple employers new employment and skill needs to the This trend is also leading to new that with workers. After a on the impact of COVID-19 on gig workers, CEO and of an staffing platform stated, workers have already an essential role in an even greater economic during the COVID-19 pandemic and will play a critical role in 2020). COVID-19 related drastically the American workforce. in the middle skill workforce are working from but nearly of all articles in this study the that the majority of middle skill workers who are essential workers who are to into the to work for workers, there were many in articles made up of company filings and congressional publications by The and and corporate CEOs for and and of workers who must enter the COVID-19 has of and new for workplace and particularly for workers who are to work in reported strategies to the of their workforce and workplace To the workers, many companies public which included use of face and and of daily and for companies and have also reported the use of strategies such as generally reducing the number of workers and temporary work to reduce and better the number of people at the these measures the work requirements of the middle skill workforce has in COVID-19 this workforce. The COVID-19 outbreak has also to and which and and economic media articles of newswires, and news from national by and National reported the types of and by COVID-19. and of news and congressional reports identified and issues of by COVID-19. A common reported throughout these articles identified an in cases of COVID-19 and middle skill workers and of the and The reason for the in cases these was to being more to work in jobs requiring more and less access to healthcare et al., 2020; States News Service, 2020; 2020). Another that was throughout media as being impacted by the COVID-19 outbreak was who are more to be than also additional challenges in managing while and were (McKinsey & 2020). This lack of access to with the of many middle skill workers to into work is to gaps in employment and This for them to between work and taking care of their et al., 2020). Prior to COVID-19, the labor to but this new crisis to these and the challenges by working (McKinsey & 2020). COVID-19 was reported to have more affected and middle skill and The pandemic is also predicted to have longer lasting on these While many middle skill workers were to many more were
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kristin Frady (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: