Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Objective To determine the accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging criteria for the early diagnosis of multiple sclerosis in patients with suspected disease.Design Systematic review.Data sources 12 electronic databases, citation searches, and reference lists of included studies. Review methodsStudies on accuracy of diagnosis that compared magnetic resonance imaging, or diagnostic criteria incorporating such imaging, to a reference standard for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis.Results 29 studies (18 cohort studies, 11 other designs) were included.On average, studies of other designs (mainly diagnostic case-control studies) produced higher estimated diagnostic odds ratios than did cohort studies.Among 15 studies of higher methodological quality (cohort design, clinical follow-up as reference standard), those with longer follow-up produced higher estimates of specificity and lower estimates of sensitivity.Only two such studies followed patients for more than10 years.Even in the presence of many lesions ( > 10 or > 8), magnetic resonance imaging could not accurately rule multiple sclerosis in (likelihood ratio of a positive test result 3.0 and 2.0, respectively).Similarly, the absence of lesions was of limited utility in ruling out a diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (likelihood ratio of a negative test result 0.1 and 0.5).Conclusions Many evaluations of the accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging for the early detection of multiple sclerosis have produced inflated estimates of test performance owing to methodological weaknesses.Use of magnetic resonance imaging to confirm multiple sclerosis on the basis of a single attack of neurological dysfunction may lead to over-diagnosis and over-treatment. MethodsWe identified studies, published and unpublished, by searching 12 databases from inception until September or November 2004.Search terms were "multiple sclerosis" combined with "magnetic resonance imaging" or "MRI".No language restrictions were applied.We undertook a citation search on the article reporting the McDonald 2001 criteria, 4 screened reference lists of included studies, and assessed studies included in the NICE multiple sclerosis guidelines.5 Studies were eligible that compared magnetic resonance imaging (or diagnostic criteria incorporating such imaging) to a reference standard for the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis and reported sufficient data to enable a 2×2 table of test Additional information and references w1-w43 are on bmj.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Whiting et al. (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: