Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
As geothermal development expands globally as part of low-carbon energy transitions, projects increasingly intersect with Indigenous cultural landscapes and governance rights. In Aotearoa New Zealand and Hawai‘i, geothermal resources are both materially valuable and culturally significant, yet the regulatory systems governing their use differ in how they recognise Indigenous interests. This paper presents a comparative analysis of Māori and Kanaka Maoli perceptions of geothermal utility to examine how governance structures shape the conditions under which geothermal development becomes culturally legitimate or contested. The analysis draws on qualitative engagement with Kanaka Maoli informants alongside synthesis of prior research relating to Māori geothermal governance and cultural perspectives in Aotearoa New Zealand. The analysis shows that Indigenous positions on geothermal development are not reducible to simple binaries of acceptance or resistance. Rather, they emerge from the interaction of local geothermal characteristics, spiritual relationships with geothermal landscapes, and the degree to which regulatory systems provide pathways for Indigenous authority, benefit-sharing, and consent. In Aotearoa, statutory recognition of Māori relationships with geothermal resources enables negotiated forms of development, including Indigenous-led initiatives. In contrast, Hawai‘i's regulatory framework provides limited mechanisms for incorporating Kanaka Maoli authority. This structural difference helps explain divergent Indigenous perceptions of geothermal utility despite shared spiritual values. The findings suggest that culturally acceptable energy pathways depend less on cultural attitudes toward technology itself, and more on whether governance systems enable meaningful Indigenous participation. For impact assessment practice, the study highlights the importance of moving beyond procedural consultation toward regulatory arrangements that recognise Indigenous authority as a determinant of project legitimacy.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Taute et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: