Key result
Online family functioning questionnaires show no difference in score variances versus paper-and-pencil formats.
Why the study?
Commonly used family functioning questionnaires have traditionally been administered on paper, but online administration has become more common, motivating validation of online versions.
Are online versions of family functioning questionnaires as reliable as paper-and-pencil versions in healthy individuals?
Cross-Sectional (n=310)
Randomized crossover order
Are online versions of family functioning questionnaires as reliable as paper-and-pencil versions in healthy individuals?
Online versions of common family functioning questionnaires are reliable alternatives to traditional paper-and-pencil formats.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports online use of these scales in healthy adults; leaves open validation in clinical populations.
BACKGROUND: Family functioning relies on different factors that are related to the individual characteristics of each member, the social context in which the family nucleus is integrated, and the internal and interpersonal family factors. The Short Version of the Family Assessment Measure-III, Dyadic Adjustment Scale, Inventory of Parent and Peer Attachment, Twenty-item Toronto Alexithymia Scale, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale, and Multidimensional Scale of Perceived Social Support are among the most commonly employed self-report measures for the assessment of family functioning and related factors. Traditionally, these scales have been administered using paper-and-pencil versions. However, with increased access to the Internet, online administration of questionnaires has become more common. The present study aimed to validate an online version of each of the above-mentioned questionnaires in a heterogeneous sample of Italian healthy individuals. METHODS: One-hundred participants were recruited for each questionnaire. A crossover design was used in each validation. The minimum important difference (MID) was applied to evaluate the differences in the variances of the paper-and-pencil and online format scores. A MID >0.5 is a reasonable first approximation of a threshold of important change. Taking into account the cross over design, mean difference between pencil-and-paper and online versions, and Intraclass Correlation Coefficient were also estimated by mixed models. RESULTS: The MID was <0.5 for all the instruments used. Therefore, no significant difference was observed between the score variances of the paper-and-pencil and online formats of all the questionnaires. Moreover, for each questionnaire the difference between the means of online and paper-and-pencil administrations scores (mean O-P) was calculated. We reported 95% confidence intervals that did not include the 0; therefore, mean (O-P) was not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: The current findings indicate that the online versions of all the questionnaires we administered can be considered reliable tools for the assessment of family functioning and related factors.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lavorgna et al. (2020) conducted a cross-sectional in Healthy individuals (n=310). Online administration of questionnaires vs. Paper-and-pencil administration was evaluated on Minimum important difference (MID) in score variances between paper-and-pencil and online formats (MID < 0.5). Online administration of the Brief FAM-III, DAS, IPPA, TAS-20, HADS, and MSPSS questionnaires showed no significant difference in score variances compared to paper-and-pencil formats, with a minimum important difference <0.5 for all instruments.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: