Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Stories abound in writing center lore reporting strained, even hostile, relationships between the English department and/or writing program and the writing center, particularly a center that employs peer tutors.Certainly such conflicts involve many issues besides our perceptions of tutoring and teaching.Nonetheless, more productive conversation could result when teachers and tutors have clearer concepts of what each does, why, where their roles overlap, converge, or blend, and how they can more positively reinforce one another.In this article, I will analyze the ways writing center personnel have discussed the concepts of teaching and tutoring, ways which I believe limit possibilities for creative thinking.My argument is that we need words and images to think about "tutoring" and "teaching" other than the two primary ways of visualizing those concepts we have developed so far -either as points on a continuum or as dichotomies in binary oppositions.I suggest instead we use language that creates images of a dialectical process.In this process, forces are held in tension by their oppositions, as they slowly embrace elements of the other, ultimately emerging into a new concept.With this in mind, I first summarize the dialogues in our journals about teaching and tutoring.I then consider ways a conscious use of the dialectical image may answer some of the important questions raised by writing center specialists about writing center tutoring, classroom teaching, and the language of writing center discourse.Finally, I offer specific examples of application of these concepts.Many writing center specialists already have called for more discussion of teaching and of tutoring.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Helon Howell Raines (1994) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: