Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Comparative modeling study reveals divergent population status estimates from single-sex versus two-sex models in European hake, highlighting the need for sex-structured stock assessments.
The integration of separate sexes in stock assessment models represents an advancement towards more realistic modeling of interactions between fisheries and target species. However, increased model complexity can also introduce additional uncertainty into the modeling process. Assuming the same biological parameters for males and females in a single‐sex model may not be appropriate for species with significant sexual size dimorphism (SSD), such as the European hake ( Merluccius merluccius ). In this study, we investigated how single‐sex assessment models assuming biological traits (I) combined for males and females, and (II) the female‐only, compare to the population dynamics of a reference two‐sex model, which accounts for sex‐specific differences in growth and natural mortality ( M ). Results show that single‐sex approaches, particularly the female‐only model, may lead to a different population status, underscoring the sensitivity of assessment outputs and management quantities to sex‐structure assumptions in SSD species. However, when sex‐structured survey data are unavailable, a single‐sex combined model may still provide a reasonable approximation of a two‐sex dynamic. Additionally, the two‐sex model's specific indicators such as sex ratio‐at‐length and operational sex ratio (OSR) provide further insights into stock and fishery dynamics, facilitating more informed decision‐making and enabling the development of fleet‐tailored management strategies. Our findings underscore the need for two‐sex models in species with marked SSD and advocate for investment in sex‐specific data collection and refined diagnostic tools to accurately assess model adequacy.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Izquierdo et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: