Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Computational modeling reveals comparative trade-offs among candidate fusion fuels, demonstrating optimized reactor configurations for energy production and breeding.
Fuel choice is the most consequential and the most emotionally contested decision in a fusion program: the pull toward the aneutronic ideal routinely overrides the reaction physics. We grade the four candidate fuels — deuterium–tritium (D–T), deuterium–deuterium (D–D), deuterium–helium-3 (D–^3He), and proton–boron-11 (p–^11B) — on one quantitative ruler, deriving each axis from first principles rather than asserting it. Using the Bosch–Hale Maxwellian-reactivity parametrization and the Nevins–Swain p–^11B fit, we compute the reactivity ladder (T), the branch-resolved neutron fraction f_n, the ideal-ignition triple product, and the fusion-to-bremsstrahlung ratio across 1–500 keV, and we close the recoverable-power side of the ledger with a direct-energy-conversion (DEC) efficiency. D–T has the highest reactivity at the lowest temperature but is ≈ 80% neutronic and consumes tritium; D–D needs no tritium but is ≈ 66% neutronic (semi-catalyzed) and low-reactivity; D–^3He is only ≈ 5.44% neutronic — the neutrons arising entirely from an unavoidable D–D side channel — but requires helium-3 that Earth does not hold in bulk; p–^11B is effectively aneutronic (<0.2%) yet demands the highest temperature, radiates hardest, and has never reached net gain. We then show that the Kronos architecture follows the scorecard rather than the ideal. A first-principles 0-D power balance run on a GPU high-performance-computing (HPC) campaign reproduces the frozen anchors of the Kronos design register: the D–T spherical-tokamak breeder (Q=3.076, P_ fus=85.04 MW, I_p=9.66 MA, f_n=79.7%), where the neutron and the bred material are the product; and the D–^3He tandem-mirror burner (Q_E=1.318, P_ fus=4298.5 MW, f_n=5.44%, plug field 26.49 T, DEC efficiency η=0.49), where power is the product and neutrons are the liability. A branch-power reconstruction recovers the 5.44% neutron fraction to within 0.01%, and a fuel-mix optimization places the engineering-gain optimum at the same helium-3 fraction that minimizes the neutron burden. The one honest cost of the D–^3He choice — fuel availability — is met by the breeder's co-product helium-3 and is otherwise lunar-gated. Every Kronos operating number is a frozen anchor in the de-risking register. Key results (frozen anchors): f_n = 79.7 %; f_n = 5.44 %; A_r = 5.41 ×10^-21; tau_E = 3 n; C_B = 5.34 ×10^-37; svq = 8.95 ×10^-22. Methods & codes: OpenMC, DAGMC, ENDF/B-VIII.0, Bosch–Hale. Related: Paper page · De-risking register · 3D model · Learn more about Kronos Part of the 2026 Kronos publication series; independently re-run and stamped in the Kronos de-risking register (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.22645689). All numerical values are frozen design-point anchors; see the register. Public research artifact. No proprietary, financial, or supply-chain information is included. Note (REPLACE): This record supersedes a prior published version. The exact superseded DOI is pending founder confirmation (see SUPERSESSION_REVIEW.csv); an isNewVersionOf relation will be added before upload. Not yet asserted.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ford et al. (2026) studied this question.