Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Theoretical analysis demonstrates the nonexistence of persistent localized fields in unbounded vacuum, highlighting that stable classical particles require gauge coupling or external trapping.
Classical-field models of the electron require a localized field configuration that persists in a linear, source-free field on unbounded space. We show that for linear source-free fields this is excluded by theorem, and we locate where the missing structure must enter. Theorem A, given two independent proofs, states that a finite-energy source-free Maxwell field on unbounded vacuum R3 whose energy density is stationary or time-periodic in some inertial frame is the zero field. Its scalar/Klein–Gordon corollary (Theorem A′ ), stated for constant coefficients on R3 without boundaries or trapping, transports the obstruction to a linear wave carrier: the massless case closes by the transferred strong-Huygens argument, the gapped case by the spectral argument through the Ruelle–Amrein–Georgescu–Enss (RAGE) theorem; spatially varying coefficients or an added trapping potential lie outside the hypotheses, and are where bound states can arise. A zero-net-flux proposition records that every closed surface carries vanishing electric and magnetic flux. The results assemble established tools—local energy decay, RAGE, the co-area formula— under explicitly fenced hypotheses, and use them to place the wave-electron models: each posits persistence at a stratum where one hypothesis fails. What survives names the additional structures through which localization or charge may enter: a time-dependent internal phase, gauge coupling, or topology in the sources or the potential sector; source-free field-line topology alone disperses under Theorem A. Companion paper: "Schrödinger as the Envelope Equation of a Gapped Electromagnetic Carrier", DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21534577 (all versions). The two papers are co-posted and cross-cite by concept DOI. Version 2 (September 2026). Substantially revised. Principal changes since v1: (i) the Beltrami/closure theorem (formerly Theorem B) has been excised in full — the reason of record is that under the monochromatic field pin the Ampère law forces the Beltrami current to vanish, and the printed closure quantity omitted a k^-3 scale factor; the paper now presents Theorem A (two proofs), its constant-coefficient scalar/Klein–Gordon corollary A′, and the zero-net-flux proposition; (ii) the A′ proof is rewritten in the unitary energy representation a± = (Ωφ ± i∂ₜφ)/√2, with the massless case closed by the transferred strong-Huygens argument alone and the gapped case by a RAGE argument through a compact resolvent composition; (iii) the frame-transfer of finite energy (|P| ≤ E/c) is now stated at hypothesis (H1), with the scalar mirror restricted to v = c; (iv) the Wolff and Williamson–van der Mark placements are rebuilt as explicit three-horn trilemmas; (v) linearity is stated as an explicit fenced hypothesis (HS0) for the scalar corollary, with a distributional-regularity remark following the zero-net-flux proposition; (vi) the abstract, keywords, declarations, and the hypothesis language for spatially varying coefficients are rewritten and standardized; (vii) all printed record DOIs now use the Zenodo concept (all-versions) DOIs so citations resolve to the newest version. A complete change ledger (paper0_delta_v1.0_to_v1.18.txt) and a latexdiff of the full revision (paper0-diff-v1.0-v1.18.pdf) accompany this version.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gruenberg et al. (2026) studied this question.